For me, and it's just me, I can tolerate about anything from a person who respects animals (mostly from vegetarians and vegans): They can dislike people, and that's OK with me as long as they respect animals. I am sure there would be exceptions, but that's the general principle.

A "good" person (whatever it means) who is indifferent or cruel to animals, I can't take.

So if I had the choice, I would prefer a "bad" person (whatever it means) who is kind to animals than a good person who is not.

I have been like that all my life. Not going to change, for sure.