TEACHERS DISCUSSION FORUM
View Thread · Previous · Next Return to Index › NYT columnist David Brooks on how to resist/sublimate being insulted online
Curious - 2015-02-07

To the posters on this forum who suffer from other posters' comments (those allowed online by the moderators): You are not alone! It's a universal plight!!!

If you read the online versions of newspaper columns you can click over to the reader comments, which are often critical, vituperative and insulting.

It’s too psychologically damaging to read these comments as evaluations of my intelligence, morals or professional skill. But if I read them with the (possibly delusional) attitude that these are treasured friends bringing me lovely gifts of perspective, then my eye slides over the insults and I can usually learn something. The key is to get the question of my self-worth out of the way — which is actually possible unless the insulter is really creative.

It’s not only newspaper columnists who face this kind of problem. Everybody who is on the Internet is subject to insult, trolling, hating and cruelty. Most of these online assaults are dominance plays. They are attempts by the insulter to assert his or her own superior status through displays of gratuitous cruelty toward a target.

The natural but worst way to respond is to enter into the logic of this status contest. If he puffs himself up, you puff yourself up. But if you do this you put yourself and your own status at center stage. You enter a cycle of keyboard vengeance. You end up with a painfully distended ego, forever in danger, needing to assert itself, and sensitive to slights.

Clearly, the best way to respond is to step out of the game. It’s to get out of the status competition. [...] The person who can quiet the self can see the world clearly, can learn the subject and master the situation.

David then proceeds to compare online trolling with the psychological dynamics of ISIS's acts of barbarism in the Middle East.

In this column, I’ve tried to describe the interplay of conflict and ego, in arenas that are trivial (the comments section) and in arenas that are monstrous (the war against the Islamic State). In all cases, conflict inflames the ego, distorts it and degrades it.

The people we admire break that chain. They quiet the self and step outside the status war. They focus on the larger mission. They reject the puerile logic of honor codes and status rivalries, and enter a more civilized logic, that doesn’t turn us into our enemies.

View Thread · Previous · Next Return to Index › NYT columnist David Brooks on how to resist/sublimate being insulted online





Go to another board -