Our opinions are obviously based on historical evidence.

I think that is what "Phil" was referring too. Sometimes we need evidence based on facts that are current particularly in relation to China. A lot of people find this board through searches related to intended employment (I know I did) and one of the first things I noticed was a bunch of people ranting about this and that but not really giving real insight into things happening now. This is of significant importance to those in or intending to be in China as things change in a short space of time.

BTW, this board is not just about China, ESL is not just about China.

I don't think anyone said it was. It's just point of fact that many people come onto this board with issues pertaining to China so of course this gets the most hits.