TEACHERS DISCUSSION FORUM
View Thread · Previous · Next Return to Index › You're wrong - all over
writpetition - 2005-02-26

If specifying race is not racist, what then IS racist, asking a teacher for his mom's name? God, help these polemists

> To those who cry "Race!' whenever the word "White!" is used. Surely an employer is entitled to specify his reasonable requirements
> in a respectful way
.

By all means! Reasonable , you said didn't you? Is race requirement a reasonable requirement?

Let a Chinese based English language school specify candidates from those countries where the people are descended originally from the British. The British still do speak the best English after all. He is paying the salary. It is his school's reputation that is at stake and he carries the can if it all goes wrong because of foreign teachers who cannot speak English any better than his Chinese staff. It is not the employer who demands white
people, it is his customers - the students
.
They recognise that African and Indian people in the main have very heavy and pronounced un-English accents and they don't want any of that.
The black people from Africa and the brown ones from India and Pakistan are speakers of English only as a second language - and not native.

How uninformed and prejudiced! Please visit http://www.y-axis.com/Teachers/uk/india.shtml and read Jill McGivering's report there. It begins, "A British company which recruits teachers for UK schools is starting for the first time to recruit from India. Also, please visit http://education.guardian.co.uk/tefl/story/0,5500,1355064,00.html

Moreover it has been taught wholly within their own grossly corrupt systems. Where, in most cases, if you pay your course fees in advance and turn up for the majority of the lessons, you are quite
literally guaranteed your degree or TEFL Certificate no matter how good or bad you are. Thus most of their certificates and degrees are handed out willy nilly only to those who can afford the course fees. I have lived and worked in India and in Africa so please do NOT argue with me on this point.

Lies! Dark, prejudiced, uninformed lies! Instead of making outright sweeping allegations against alien countries please enlighten with secular proof. Anybody can make sweeping allegations against anyone else but the one doing this shows his integrity or the lack of it.

> The problem with Chinese students is that they only ever hear English being spoken by other Chinese students and rarely by foreigners whose MOTHER tongue is English
.

Really? Don't they have televisions, radios, tapes and CD's in China where they can hear people whose "Mother tongue" is English?

Do you think Chinese language schools don't recognise this? Do you seriously believe that they MUST employ Africans,Indians and other races, whose grasp of English is no better (and in many cases worse) than their own, simply to satisfy the
"politically correct" but patently jealous ravings of so-called anti-racialists?

If an Indian writer is good enough to write in English and win the Booker Prize and numerous other globally recognized literary awards does that not bear testimony to the Indians' skill in the language? Please visit http://www.chillibreeze.com/articles/EnglishinIndia.asp and don't forget to what's written there. And, please learn to respect others for their knowledge.

You "anti-racist" people don't even realise that by championing the black races you are quite consciously behaving worse than you accuse us white people of doing. All we (and our Chinese
employers) are guilty of, is recognising that the British, Americans, Canadians, Australians, New Zealanders and Irish definitely speak the best English. We're not in demand for the colour of our skin but for our ability to speak English well. Though being white is good, for it is also an easily recongnisable indicator of our origins - in much
the same way that being black is - only the origins are unquestionably different and the problem is that no matter whose passports black people carry there's nothing they can do to disguise their skin colour.
It must be tough - but if Kiswahili or Hindi ever become internationally desirable languages, I wonder how many white people the Africans and Indians will employ to teach them.

If that's really true, how come even the UK is inviting English teachers from India?
Your unreasonable rant is proof of your racist dredentials. Like the KKK to which you probably belong, you would love to exterminate all the coloured people of the world. But, you CAN'T!

You may rave and rant as you like, but we will use reason and argument to prove that you are merely a bigoted fool who is a shame to humanity!

Get smart or you'll get your just desserts!

Messages In This Thread
You're wrong - all over -- writpetition -- 2005-02-26
Showing the Face of Reason are you? -- Dave -- 2005-02-28
Reason... Pure reason -- writpetition -- 2005-02-28
View Thread · Previous · Next Return to Index › You're wrong - all over





Go to another board -