SCHOOLS AND RECRUITERS REVIEWS
Return to Index › n/a
#1 Parent Ian McAllister - 2008-09-02
Re: n/a

Choatle, mate, why are you still in China? It sounds like Hell!
Ian

#2 Parent Choatle - 2008-07-11
Re: n/a

I agree with some of the things you said, but even I found your post to be a little negative. However I did agree with some of the things you said, but only to a point.

Yes, it is true there's no way to know if the person your talking to does actually work for, or did work for the school you are thinking of working for. That is why you don't ask for just one name, but three. Any school should have no problem scrounging up the names and phone numbers of 3 people who worked for them prioer, or who do now. If they can't, than be wary. It's a alot less likely that a school will be able to locate and coerce three seperate foreigners into lying about having worked there, and ebing thorough enough to have them all tell the same lies.

Yeah, schools change their names online, sometimes, but rarely. In the end though that's not as common as this poster pointed out. It's the recruiters and middle men agents like Miss Liu and Yuncheng IELTS school that use different names on a regular basis. They operate in a grey area of psuedo legality, which often crosses that thin red line into full illegality, so it;s no wonder they have so many aliases. Schools though, it's a lot harder to change your name. If someone gives you a school name and you can find zero about it, not even a web site, that might be an indicator something is wrong. Might I say, because I have tried to research well knwon school and had a hard time finding information about them online. This could also be seen as good, since usually it's only if your bad that yuo have things posted about you in the ESL and EFL world.

I'd agree, I had no cushy life back home in my country, long work weeks, tight budget, often living from week to week, a very common stry for most foreigers who come here. I have found far less stress working and living here, as money is easier to come by and make than it was in my home country. Not having as many worries is certainly a thing that makes me very happy.

Basicaly I agree with the things the poster said, to a point, however I think they are being a bit too negative, only because they give no solution to the problems proposed.

Yes, schools lie, people lie, all truth, but that does not mean there is not a solution. Comon sense realy is a powerful tool you know, and in the end, someone can simply say no. I will admit, finding work here can be a big problem, trust being a major issue. You just have to grit your teeth and make the best decision possible. Sometimes it works out, sometimes you get screwed. However, your a heck of a lot more likely to make a good decision if you follow my advice and that of others like turnoi and silverboy, than to just get so gun shy that you do nothing, believe me.

Always ask to speak with at least 3 current employees, if they don't have, then prior employees. Don't get emails, because you'll just get some Chinese people emailing you pretending to be FT's.

Ask for a website. Most legite schools have websites. Ask for an address, a school can claim a different name, but not a different address. If you google an address and it comes back with a different school name, hmm, somethings fishy. If you have difficulty searching using English, ask a Chinese friend to do it.

Make sure the school sends you pictures of the apartment you will live in. Make sure it will have everything you need, from internet access to a computer to hot water. Believe me, you'd be amazed at what some apartments are lacking in regards to the most common and necessary of things.

Ask a lot of questions. Sit down and make up a list of all the things you want to know about. here is a sample.

1. How many classes a week will I be teaching. Classes, not hours. Actual hours and actual number of classes is a bait and switch scam that school have been running for years to confuse teachers. Don't get hours confused with number of classes, schools like to say 25 hours, but that's actually just them counting the number of minutes in each class and converting it to hours.

2.How ong is each class, always remember to ask that one, some schools are now teaching super long classes of one or even 2 hours in length.

3.Is it a public or private school. While a seemingly small matter, it really isn't. A public school is more likely to treat you better. It's no guarantee, but it's more likely. Also, private schools, always, always make more money. If you are ebing offered a job teaching 20 classes for 5,000 at a private school, then I'd pass, you can get working public.

4.Are there any office hours? Schools will often intice you with low classes higher pay. However, they will often leave out all the extra work they expect you to do. Interviewing students, taking time to help them after classes, or just having to be there for whatever, is inb my opinion work. If your requiring me to be there and I may indeed have things to do that come up, I'm working. You will never get paid for this time, so if there are 25 classes in a week, and it's a 40 hours week, your spending 20 hours sitting on your butt or working on and off throughout the day. It's all free work to, so be sure you ask about this.

5. Do they cover the cost of electricity and water. Not so small a thing, believe me. If it's hot, or cold enough, say good bye to a few hundred atleast per month if they don't cover these necessities.

6. Where is the apartment located, on or off campus? Believe me, off campus is better. If on campus, look forward to being locked in after a certain time, and not being able to get out, or back in without a real hassle. Are you a prisoner, nah, your just surrounded by walls and can't go anywhere until 7 am. While in truth you could, there will be a night guard, he must first be there, or awake, and maybe even then he'll give you a hard time. Personally I prefer off campus.

7. How much paid vacation do I get? Very important question, and one most FT's completely glance over. What you folks don't realize is that, if you work for a public school, your going to be getting two months off of work, fully paid. If you work for a private training school, you won't get that time. You will get some aid holidays, which all together add up to a decent amount, but you also get those at a public schol, plus the summer and winter holiday paid, which rivate schools don't give. Something to keep in mind when job hunting.

8.How much time is there in between classes? This is another question asked by almost no FT's here. Say your first class is at 9am. Great, when is my second class? Seem like no big deal? Only if you don't mind spending 9 hours working to teach just 4 classes. Schools can be tricky. They want you to be there the maximum amount of time for the minimum amount of pay. However, some schools are real whores in this regard, and will gorge and gouge you to the fullest extent. It is not uncommon for some teacher to go in and sart at 8:30, and not be done until 8:30 that night. Yet they only ended up teaching 4 classes that day. Now, I don't care if I can go home, or do what I like between classes, I want my day to be over by a reasonable time. If I have to leave and go home 4 times a day, well damn, that's some tiring, well, you know. Make sure your schedule is a reasonable one, without huge gaps in between classes.

9. How many students would be in each class? As someone who has taught as many as 70 middle school age kids, I can tel you, it's no picinic sometimes. While you can control that many "most" of the time if you are a decent teacher, it is quite difficult to teach so many people fo so young and age. If someone tels you classes will have over 50 students, well, you might want to reconsider. It is posible to do, but you must be a skilled teacher right out the gate, otherewise they will eat you alive.

10. What is the name of the school? That one seem obvious? You'd be amazed how many people overlook that one.

11.Is over time required? Another often mised one. Often schools will tel you how many classes you will be teaching, if you ask, but they are realy only teling you how many you'll teach during their "slow" times. Some schools are now offering contracts which have different work hours for differen times of year. Make sure this ain't the case, and that you have the same amount fo hours, and they are agreed upon as the "maximum" amount. No words like "may" or "minimum", make sure the maximum amount is spelled out, and that nothing in the contract is vague.

12. Can I see a copy of the contract? That's pretty common, and usually a school will send you one. However for some reason, for the purpose of deceit of course, they will send you a sample. I do not kid you when I tel you I have received contracts that were samples alright, and not even about the job I was applying for. Never accept sample contracts, they are indeed that, just samples. Make sure you see the actual contract you will be signing, it will answer many of your questions if it is not a sample. however, ask the quesitons anyway. Also, make sure to explore any vague language, now matter how trivial a matter it may be. Any vague area will be exploited to your detriment.

13. Can I see pictures of the school? If they give you a website address, this may be moot, but I always ask anyway, as homemade pcitures can give me some clues that website pictures don't. You never know.

14. Do you cover all visa costs? This one is very important really. Some here in China are not, well, working on the best visa, that's all I'll say. Whatevr your visa though, the school should cover all costs. The best schools, if they must have you go to HK, will even give you travel money for expenses, since HK is not cheap at all. Whatever the case, a school should cover all expenses, even if you are getting the visa before you come. You must make sure this is in writing and in your contract.

15. Would I receive a holiday travel allowance? Almost al schools give this, and it usually a one time fee during either the summer or winter holiday, depending on when you start. The amount is between 1,100 and 2,200 rmb. This is common, and any good school will offer it.

16. How much is airfare reimbursement? This one is very important, and a dying practice. Schools are getting so greedy they try and find more and more ways to screw you over. This is one. Generally airfare reimbursement is equal to one month salary. If your only making 5,000 though, I would say it should be at least 7,000. If more than 7,000, it in my opinion should be equal to that amount. This "bonus" as it is called is becoming a thing of the past. Ask for it, most schools still offfer a bonus, some though are trying to get rid of it. I have seen some school offering just 3,000, absurd of course. I could not buy a ticket to the USA for 3,000.

17. How many students attend your school over all? I always ask this, just to see how big and successful a school is. If they try to claim poverty or hard times, yet they are a private school with 10,000 students in a poor city, I will be skeptical.

18. Do you provide health insurance or accident insurace? Most decent schools will provide some kind of health coverage and or coverage in case of an accident. Make sure to ask for the exact amount of protection offered, if you don't ask this, they sure won't tell.

19.What hours would I be working? Another often ignored question, and very important. Many coming here assume they will be doing 9 to 5, or 8 to 5. nope. Schols have split schedules as often as not, and you may find yourself having to come back for a second shift in the evening. Ask this question always, and get details.

20. What days would I be working? Another obvious question which is just as obviously over looked by the over eager expat. 5 days a week does not mean you will have weekends off, and if it's a private school, you likely won't. Maybe you get two days off, but not back to back. Or maybe you are working 6 days a week. There are many piggish schols out there pushing the envelope because of expats who are professional stoics who will take just about any punishment that can be dished out. Expect schools to try and take advantage unless you put a stop to it before it happens. Ask questions ask questions ask questions. if they have a problem with answering them, walk.

21. Where is the school? Another question that is often overlooked, though I'll admit not as much as some of the others. I hve knowon teachers who forget as quickly as they were told where. Make a point of knowing and of researching the area. How many people live there, where is the region in regards to it's economic development. Is it rich, poor? Al these things can and do factor into salary.

22. How much is the salary? This ones a no brainer, but it's amazing how many no brains there are out there. Always ask this, especially if using a recruiter, God forbid you actually do. Often recruiters will say one number, which is totally fictional. You'd be amazed how many Ft's take the recruiters word and never even think to ask the school the one time they talk to them before departing for their new job. Always ask.

23.How much paid vacation time do I get? This is in regards to private schools for the most part. In addition to paid holidays you should get some personal vacation time. Generally it is 2 weeks, some places it might be more, but I wouldn;t bet on it. These places are in business year round. However, some places will offer more time, sometimes upaid, because of a drop off in students. This leads to your next question.

24. How much unpaid leave is there? Some language schools are hurting, usually because of poor management, imagine that. Make sure there is no unpaid leave, or if there is, how much time is it. It's never fun to go work somewhere, only to find that half way through your gonna loose a month of salary.

25. What amenities does my apartment have? While pitures speak a thousand words, they don't always show everything. Ask if there is a dvd, stove, ask if it is electric or gas. Does it have a microwave, washer. While the microwave is unlikely, the washer should not be. I have heard stories of people having to hand wash clothes though. Is there a phone, and if so, who covers the cost? Internet and computer, and if so, who covers the internet cost? You;d be amazed how much these things add up.

26. This is more advice than a question, but watch out for the word "tax" in Chinese contracts. While it's not always the case, sometimes a school will try and tax you far more than is legally acceptable, and all they end up doing is pocketing the money anyhow. As I said, not always the case, but be wary when you see it in a contract. Make sure the taxation is legal and of legal percentage.

That's it, these questions should allow you to find out all you need to know about any school your considering working for. I hope it helps some newbies out there considering coming to work here.

#3 Parent Realist - 2008-07-10
Re: n/a

Isn't it strange how many "misfits" there seem to be here in China and posting negative reports about schools and recruiters? Why do you claim that their experiences heve embittered them to the point of absurdity and an inability to paint a true picture? Many people of your attitude claim these and similar things but never explain WHY there are SO MANY negative reports here on this and other boards. Perhaps every " negative " poster is a misfit or perhaps.....
You talk about "...the absence of the cushy life they experienced in the West". Why would anyone travel ( at their own expense ) to an alien country and culture to work if their life was "cushy" in the West?
You say that "They only write about the problems and have never imagined a solution". Have you actually read their posts? Isn't the overiding solution that employers, agents and schools STOP LYING TO and CHEATING FT's and treat us with honesty, integrity and respect? and that this will be reciprocated? Or is that " Rocket science" to you?
You advise that prospective FT's "Properly research any school..." ummmmmm...how? Don't some "schools" (and agents) change their names regularly to avoid the bad reports they recieve from FT's?
" undergo direct contact.. " What happens when they LIE?
" Make sure you contact teachers who've worked there before" Errrr how do you know they have?
" Don't use recruiters.......avoid working in private schools..." Is that an admission that there are serious problems in dealing with these people? and does that make you " a misfit" too?
" Be humble" Yes Sir, No Sir, three bags full Sir !
" Expect the unexpected ". Booked your travel tickets for the day after the end of term only to be told ( a few hours before ) you have to work an extra few days? You should have expected that so it's YOUR FAULT !
"....you will see and experience things you could only imagine right now"
How very true that is! Some things here you could not imagine in your worst nightmare!
I suppose this post makes me a " misfit " "whiner" "whinger" " China basher" " anti Chinese" etc. etc. Still rather that than an naive, misguided APOLOGIST!

#4 Parent Choatle - 2008-07-10
Re: n/a

I don't see any advice worth following from this person. Psychology is a soft science my friend, and for a good reason. You sound more like a self help book than anything else. While your words sound rosy and sweet, in truth they don't reflect the reality of life. You also speak of people you actually don't know, so your making statements based upon nothing.

As for not having the same cushy life as we do back home. Come on, often we have it as good or better because of our high salaries relatively speaking. However that's just money. It doesn't speak to the often poor treatment, lies, corruption, or poor business practices we often must endure. Also, for each one of us who has it good, some poor fellow has a toilet that doesn't work, no hot water, and cockroaches the size of an NFL linebacker.

Before you portray those of us who portray the "reality" for a majority of FT over here as pansies, better get your facts straight. You are one of the lucky few who has not had too much of a terrible nature happen to him. Do you honestly think that makes you the majority, or just lucky?

I would say my picture is pretty true. Almost zero standards for real education, no idea how to educate, corruption, greediness so bad that it destroys any chance of education. Lie's, deceit, intimidation quite often, bribes, too much quanxi for the school, not enough if any for the teacher, disrespect by our Chinese peers. No, I think I paint a pretty accurate picture.

While this is not always the case, I would say that 80% of the time it is from my experience. Those few who come on here and have experienced a lot of bad things and yack yack about how it ain't a big deal are idiots. Their choosing to ignore systemic sickness in their job, and counseling others to do the same. Not everyone ascribes to the school of stoicism though, we don't all just want to sit back, relax, and tell the fellow who's torturing us that if he bends our leg anymore it will break, than when it does simply say "See, I told you it would break." Forgive me if I don't feel like being that stoic.

Also it is irresponsible to just ignore it or "suck it up" since this mertely emboldens the school to treat other teachers who come after with less regard. Basically, those people who just "suck it up" really make it worse for the rest of us.

The truth is that the reality over here is as follows. A lot of corruption, no real idea how to educate people. Too many private English training schools, too little understanding of western style teaching techniques. Add in the fact that so many Chinese collegues suffer from envy because they know what we make, and it can make for a not so good situation.

That's not to say that people don't find good jobs all the time, where they are treated well, but believe me when I tell you, that's not the majority.

And as I and others have said before, we are not here to market or "sell" any schools. If their doing their job well we have no need to talk about them.

Were not here because we hate China or dislike Chinese at all. Were not anti China. Were anti bad business and corruption. Were pro teachers, and we basically want to educate people on the reality they could be in for. It does come in varying degrees as well, I can put up with a fair amount of ignorance and disrespect from other Chinese teachers, and call it a decent job. Were all different, and we all have different tolerances. That's why we come here, to this forum, to give an opinion on what seems acceptable to an FT. Now your tolerance may be different, but I and others don't account for that. We just lay everything on the table and you decide if it's acceptable or not. That you have a higher tolerance for crap is good, but don't call us anti Chinese or embittered because we simply lay things out in a stark way without taking such into account. After all, everyone is different.

The truth is, if you want an unbiased view of China, you won't get one. We all live here, and work here in one form of another. If you want to learn about the realities, use your brain and do other research. Certainly don't take my words as gospel, but don't dismiss them out of hand either. Do be careful about listening to the people who will tell you were not representing the reality of how things are over here. That just runs smack dab in the face of common sense. In truth were portraying things just as they are. It's just that others have been here for so long they have become uncaring and blind to much of it, and in I have as well, at least when on the job. However this doesn't mean I don't want to warn others, not everyone has my tolerance for BS either.

If you want to come here to teach, keep all this in mind. Corruption, lies, deceit, business above education all the time. If you can live with these things, than you will maybe have an OK stay. However if these things cause the school and staff at your school to make your life hard, you might not be so happy. Do your research, and use your gut.

In the end, research is your best friend, and I say again, were not here to give free cudo's to schools, they have ad departments for that. The day they start giving free cudos to us on their own special teachers forums, that will be the day I start advertising for them. Until then, bye.

#5 Parent leslie - 2008-07-10
Re: n/a

thanks for the reply!

i did receive an email from aclipse saying they wanted to schedule a phone interview with me, so i'll just try to make sure i take my time understanding what's what and just sit tight if they seem to have something up their sleeves.

i'm also thinking of going thru a master's program, so that's an option if the aclipse thing doesn't pan out...

#6 Parent James Mac - 2008-07-10
Re: n/a

Comments? Yes:
The few posters here who are constantly bad mouthing the teaching scene in China are simply misfits who can't see the forest for the trees. Their negative experiences have embittered them to a point of absurdity and an inability to paint a true picture. Often what they have experienced as negative is simply the absence of the cushy life they experienced in the West. They only write about the problems and have never imagined a solution.

Suggestions? Yes:
Properly research any school you'd like to work for. Undergo direct contact with the administration of those schools and the Foreign Affairs Office. Make sure you contact teachers who've worked there before. Don't use recruiters. There are a few honest ones, but not enough to make that a viable option. Avoid working for private schools in China until you've learned the ropes here. Be humble. Expect the unexpected. Don't be a pollyanna, but don't be a pessimist either. Find a balance and you will see and experience things you could only imagine right now.

leslie - 2008-07-08
n/a

i've been thinking of doing this teaching-abroad gig but after reading a lot of the threads here, it seems like i would be entering the depths of hell.

i was particularly thinking of going to china (took some years of mandarin and thought that might be helpful), korea (got hooked on some k-dramas) or japan (thought that might be the safest country, been there for vacation and impressed w/the cleanliness, friendly folks and the great grub to be found in the subway stations).

even thought of going for a master's and teaching esl in the states but it seems even if i wanted to teach in the states, most jobs want at least one year teaching experience and it's only the jobs abroad that give leeway on this.

comments? suggestions?

Return to Index › n/a





Go to another board -