SCHOOLS AND RECRUITERS REVIEWS
Return to Index › Why you should think twice about teaching in China
#1 Parent Michael - 2012-09-05
WHY YOU SHOULD NEVER TEACH IN CHINA AT ALL!

1. They will break your contract.

2. You will never hear a word of truth again.

3. You will get called Laowei incessantly.

4. Men will hock up loogies and spit them on the sidewalk when you go by.

5. Prostitutes ([edited]) will solicit you for sex.

6. You WILL break your contract!

7. You will never get out of this Hell hole again.

8. You will lose any money or self-respect you ever had.

9. You will forget what food tastes like.

10. You will see mile after mile of God-awefully ugly buildings and never remember the feeling of freedom or fresh air again.

YOU DO NOT WANT TO TEACH IN CHINA, PEOPLE! WAKE UP!

#2 Parent Liam - 2012-08-27
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

tell you what Clyde, OP, I have read your post from top to botom and all the replies at least three times before i add my reply. first of all. what you have written is so so accurate and in no way biased. it has given me much food for thought but especially concerning your acknowledgement that we are now in the midst of ramped up nationalism. In fact it seems to be getting unbearable right now to the point where any kind of disprespect is treated like a face off. China is full of arrogant assholes and i am doing my last year here then i am gone.

#3 Parent Terry - 2012-07-29
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

They don't understand their own food, Magister, how can they understand Western food? They do understand that to achieve that special pork dumpling taste, the pork should be left to go dangerously off before using it. There have been scares surrounded the likes of McDonalds in China but by and large it's likely to be safer than San Migs' fresh Chinese fish and vegetables, because McDonald itself keeps an eye out for any malpractices. Of course a lot of the food in so-called Western food restaurants in China is just as unhealthy as Chinese food proper. Egg sausage and chips, if cooked by Chinese people in China[left to their own devices] is Chinese food; it'll get the same loving care as a dish of Shanxi noodles,potato and chicken.

#4 Parent San Migs - 2012-07-29
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

You obviously have been into Starbuck, whereas i live a more frugal lifestyle. I like to try and save as much of my wages as possible. I like to take as much money as i can back home when I leave.

Now you are just being disputatious for the sake of it! I also try and save at least half of my salary each month when in china, or wherever I work, just paid a chunk into my back the other day actually....

Wtf did I say i had been to starbucks in my previous post? Nowhere, that's where. I tried it once, was treated by a friend, and never went back. I did buy some of their coffee beans which were quite good, but finished those long ago. Now I don't really like coffee, a good cup of english breakfast tea sees me right, but sorry no lipton teabags, that is just dishwater in a cup, proper yorkshire or assam tea only I am afraid.

Satisfied now terry lad?

Peace,
SMGS

#5 Parent Dragonized - 2012-07-29
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

There are many restaurants that charge twice to three times on average what you'd be paying for from a street vendor which pose as high end wannabe types with pseudo-western names. The quality of the food, though isn't any better than that of the street places. It's merely served on fancier plates with seemingly fancier furniture everywhere and maybe a few fancier sounding ingredients (some of which I'm sure they will claim to be imported) will be used on the food. These are the places where you NEVER want to waste too much money at, period.

#6 Parent Magister - 2012-07-28
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

You should still be careful of western food in china. One of the problems with it is they don't really know how to handle it and prepare it in a safe and hygienic way. You should be Particularly careful eating things like dairy products that can really hit your stomach hard. I can think of two occasions where I got a dodgy stomach from eating at western restaurants both of which had a cream content to them. Just walking into a corner shop in china you'll notice a large number of products are past there use by date. My guess is restaurants sometimes operate to similar standards.

#7 Parent Terry - 2012-07-28
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

I don't know. It would never occur to me to pay the sort of price that Starbuck demands in China. You obviously have been into Starbuck, whereas i live a more frugal lifestyle. I like to try and save as much of my wages as possible. I like to take as much money as i can back home when I leave.

#8 Parent San Migs - 2012-07-28
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

Not even going to bother, you probably think Starbucks is good coffee. Killfile.

#9 Parent Terry - 2012-07-27
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

Chinese tofu, vegetable and fish are killers if stored incorrectly and handled by a man who never washes his hands after going to the toilet; and that's the standard treatment the aforementioned get. Then more often than not they will get the old chemical treatment, MSG, to bring out the distinctive Chinese flavours. That stuff will deprive you of your eyesight for starters. On balance Mcdonald, as nasty as it is, will keep you in better health.

#10 Parent San Migs - 2012-07-27
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

You have more chance of surviving any given Western meal (even McDonald) than a Chinese one.

As mcdonalds beef burgers are only 15 percent beef, I would question that fact. I wouldn't even call mcdonalds cheese "cheese" either!

No, far better to eat chinese vegetables, tofu and fish than all that rubbish!

#11 Parent Terry - 2012-07-27
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

I'm afraid not. You have more chance of surviving any given Western meal (even McDonald) than a Chinese one. Best hope you only get a week of the runs and Hep A with the latter. Then there's the long term killers like all the oil (sometimes industrial and might kill you next day) and the MSG that they use. When in China it's best to cook your own grub, but please overcook the vegetables to get rid of special Chinese poisons that they spray them with. Bread and Australian/American butter might be safer.

#12 Parent foxy - 2012-07-26
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

Where is the butter?

Unhealthy Western food - give it up, man! I haven't eaten it or drunk milk since 1994. Fact is, Chinese food is healthier than Western food!

#13 Parent Terry - 2012-07-26
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

Well done, pleased to hear it. When I was teaching in China before I used to take advantage for my own ends, during class times sometimes. When say a group of half a dozen made it clear they didn't want to follow a lesson plan . They'd say, we want free-talk. I'd say okay but I also want you to do some translations, it's good for you(simple stuff I needed to practice and get my tones right)...like xia wo yi da tiao, you zhi zhu zai tian hua ban shang(scared the life out of me, there's a spider on the ceiling) Now say that in English ,please, i'd say, after they corrected me. i often would buy one item at a time when I went shopping to practice speaking. You shouldn't take a Chinese with you because if you ask the assistant, where is the butter, instead of trying to understand you ,she will turn to the other person and ask what this mad man is saying. They don't actually call you mad but their expressions look like they are.

#14 Parent Terry - 2012-07-26
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

What's the opposite of gilding the lily, Clyde, can't think, comes with age, something evil? But you're right ,it could be a nightmare. I will let you know if my Mandarin works for me, if it's all hail fellow, well met. In the private sector I had reached a good conversational level within 7 months and it served me very well indeed over the remaining years. But as you indicate to me life in the public domain is savage and course, so my golden tongue it seems will cut no ice. I'll give it a go, otherwise I could spend the rest of my life wondering. And I see that I have found a good avenue in this site to report back to. Go East old man and fill your boots. But what I will fill them with remains to be seen.

#15 Parent Clyde - 2012-07-26
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

Hi Terry. Hey man, you don't need to do it. Even if you bought the ticket, you don't need to go through with it. I recently heard a horror story about Jinan. Are you absolutely sure it's NOT a vocational school, and that the students are real students who got in on their merit and not on their parent's money.

4,200 is almost as low as it gets. I made that 3 years ago to teach 14 hours a week, and was also paid for 12 months. THAT was the standard government contract at the time. Chinese teachers with Master's degrees should be making more than that. They were making 5,000 where I was. So, I wonder how many hours you have, and whether you have a 10 or 12 month contract. Flight reimbursement? Do you have to do English Corners for free on top of your schedule? How many different subjects will you be teaching. Those are all things to take into consideration.

Likely you will get some serious lung infections. Also, unless it's a newly built school, you'll probably get those squat toilets as well.

None of that means you won't have a very positive experience. But, you are precisely correct about why foreign teachers need to make more money than the locals. It's because we come from a different economy, and will return to it one day. This ain't charity. One can cope with low wages, but when they dip below one's Chinese counterparts, that is a pisser.

Your contract should allow to to bail out at any point with a one month notice. If you don't happen to fall in love, or find yourself in one of the increasingly rare fair scenarios where everything is going fine (and that's STILL very possible, and some of the people on this thread have found such cushy niches for themselves I think), make some excuse and bail. I would use family illness as an excuse. You can forge a doctors note if necessary. Even if they were inclined to call your country to check, they'd probably be too cheap to make the phone call. Besides, you can get any friend to pretend to be a doctor over the phone, but it will never come to that. Just serve up the lie and that's that.

IF the shit hits the fan, or if you change you mind now, scoot over to neighboring Vietnam or Cambodia. You can always find work in those countries, though in Cambodia it's only in Phnom Phen (sp?). I think you can find work in Saigon almost instantly. There were training schools there everywhere. Visas are not really a problem in either country, especially Cambodia, as you can get a year visa that you can teach on for $230 going into the country. That could be a back-up plan.

If things are getting dark in the winter, and you're gacking up loogies and choaking them back down while trying to teach, and people are playing you like a tool, get the hey outta' there.

I think, however, that you have about a 65% chance of things being quite to your liking. Probably 80% change it's tolerable. And then there's the 20% chance it sucks. And then there's a 15% chance it's a nightmare.

Actually, I sorta' regret giving you things to worry about, because it's not really helpful. So I'm going to throw in one tip that might help you through the winter there. As soon as you start getting a tickle in your throat, start gargling with vinegar. The acid in the vinegar kills the bacteria on contact. I found doing this as much as necessary (could be as much as 5-6 times a day) in the initial phase of exposure, which usually showed up in the throat, killed that crap before I'd get yet another month long lung infection, of which I've had at least 8 or 9 while in China (that doesn't include regular colds).

So, again, best of luck to you. I believe you'll be fine. And now maybe you have some back up plans so if the shit hits the fan you don't just have to sit in your cell and get pelted full on in the face. You can turn that fan around on them and let them wallow in a shit-storm when you bail out, and they have no replacement.

Cheers

#16 Parent Clyde - 2012-07-26
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

Clyde, I do think you are somewhat over-egging the fact that foreign teachers are hard done by these days having been used to working 12-14 hours a week and now they are having to work 20.

Being paid F/T for 20 hours a week is still a cushy number considering most western countries it is a minimum of 35. I would also say that sitting in the office all day when not in a classroom, waiting for hometime (in effect, resembling a 40 hour working week) does not constitute as work either.

That's true. I've heard that argument before. If you are a teacher in the West you may teach as many hours as a full time job. You wouldn't be doing it for less than $800 a month though. If you are going to work 20 hours, the salary should at least reflect that. And it also shouldn't be that the Chinese teachers are working less hours for more pay than you get. I'm not sure exactly that comparing teaching Oral English in China can be compared to being a teacher in the West (unless you meant an ESL teacher in Europe or something). Because then you have to start thinking about things like, do you have a car in China, and could you even afford one if you wanted one. The answer is probably "no".

So, even if you can save more money in China than a teacher could in the West, because you live on campus, and even if you have more free time than a teacher in the West could dream of, you also have nothing going into your retirement, absolutely no security whatsoever (well, my uni didn't provide insurance), you don't own a home or a vehicle, don't have access to quality health care should you need it, are completely separate from your family, and otherwise live a compromised existence that simply can't be compared to being a full functional independent, employed teacher in the West. One has to keep things in perspective and the proper context. The reason to teach in China at a public university was the free time and long vacations.

Once you start working 20 hours at a uni for shit pay like 5000-6000 you might be better off working for a training school. In fact, I found training schools paying people with much less education and experience nearly double what I was being offered in universities for comparable hours within the same city. Actually, in the last place I worked, teachers at a local training school who may or may not have even had a BA, and probably didn't have a TEFL, were making more than a 1,000 yuan a month more than the university teachers, and working only 4 hours more a week. They had less benefits, but, the uni is cutting out summer vacation and tacking on duties…

#17 Parent Terry - 2012-07-26
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

Hello Clyde. It will be Jinan. I'm a bit confused, I thought we were talking about state universities and middle schools. Your graphic description of the ablutions and what used to be called French toilets( when i was in France in 1966(England won the cup) most of their matong were holes in the ground) gave me a nightmare flashback to a couple of occasions I did find myself in those teaching establishments. Being a chain-smoker has to be an advantage to work in such places I thought, because only 10% of your odour receptors are active. They should give you free fags as part of the contract.

Foreign teachers need to be paid more than local teachers because one day we have to return home; restarting your life again in the West, can be a very expensive business indeed; we don't all return to Mum and Dad's, and find our room exactly as we left it five years before. I never felt guilty earning substantially more than Chinese teachers. Your position would really get up my nose. However, my pay will be only 4200, so I could yet be confronted by Chinese teachers getting 5000. For the balance to change after you have started the job is different again, I understand. Not good at all.

#18 Parent juanisaac - 2012-07-26
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

I am with you Terry. I am learning Mandarin, reading and speaking. Whether the Chinese appreciate it or not, I don't care. I do it for myself.
Yes, I do favors for the school I work at and sometimes I do not get paid. However, you must know like me that a favored owed is a favour that must me repaid. The teachers and staff here get me students to tutor on my spare time and other odd jobs that allow me to get paid. In a good month, I double my pay staying under 40 hours per work week. I am allowed to work at TCs, and travel in China doing teacher trainings. My school knows what I do on side and they leave me alone.

When I first arrived here, I had to right every wrong and do everything the western way. As long as what I do does not conflict with my ethics, I can do it. Yes, Chinese do lie and cheat but that falls on themselves. I do not lie and I do not cheat. My school knows that.

#19 Parent anon - 2012-07-26
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

this is a good debate and the OP Clyde deserves a lot of credit for what is a well written argument, however whilst i agree with most of your opinions Clyde, I do think you are somewhat over-egging the fact that foreign teachers are hard done by these days having been used to working 12-14 hours a week and now they are having to work 20.

Being paid F/T for 20 hours a week is still a cushy number considering most western countries it is a minimum of 35. I would also say that sitting in the office all day when not in a classroom, waiting for hometime (in effect, resembling a 40 hour working week) does not constitute as work either.

#20 Parent Terry - 2012-07-26
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

If this teacher from Chicago was speaking standard English, he shouldn't have been interrupted, I agree. If he was speaking with an accent that most English, American, Australian,Canadian, etceteras, children might struggle with then this Victor would have had reason to be concerned.

#21 Parent Clyde - 2012-07-25
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

Hi Terry. You SHOULD be much better off in a public university. It's a different game, and it used to be the only safe bet. Since you are committed, you can look forward to very nice students. I'm assuming it's a "public" university, for students who actually earned their way in there, and NOT a private university for students who have money but couldn't make it into a public university (I hear those students are dreadful). But probably you will have the really good variety of students.

It'll probably be fine. If you don't know what the deal was supposed to be, you probably won't mind if you lost some of your benefits or had 2-4 hours tacked onto your schedule. A big part of my problem was the job kept getting worse. They added 2 hours, then they added bullshit classes, then the Chinese teachers all got raises and my salary fell blow theirs, then they started demanding a curriculum and lesson plans, now the are cutting out the summer vacation. So, it's intolerable for the job to get worse. But if you step into it without knowing that the standard contract used to be 12-14 hours a week, but you are working 16-20, and teachers used to get paid for 12 months a year, but you are only getting paid for 10… it won't piss you off. But you can imagine if you are someplace and they were just to say, "Hey, we're going to add 2 hours a week and reduce your pay by 10% at the same time," you'd probably want to tell them to go F themselves. But if you just walk in the door and your are working 8 more hours a week for 15% less, you can still be smiling and stupid and gullible and even do extra tasks for leaders to "show your appreciation."

Ah well, you'll have a good experience if you are a good teacher. Can I ask what city you'll be living in?

Good luck. And do take everything I've said with a grain of salt. I'm a little pissed off at China at the moment, especially because I've had a much softer landing somewhere else and wonder why I ever dealt with all that crap. There is a lot of value in living and experiencing China. It's priceless. But so much depends on the job. Still, public universities are the safest jobs in China. On the other hand I've gone back to working for a training school, but only because it's not run by businessmen, there are no leaders to deal with, no English Corners, no extra-curricular activities, and basically no bullshit whatsoever. Training schools in China can be the worst, depending on the bosshole who runs the show. I worked in one that was OK, and then really bad, and another that was absolute shit from the get-go, but could have been even worse.

Cheers.

#22 Parent foxy - 2012-07-25
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

I will remember what you said though and not teach the leaders' nippers for free.

I've heard of foolish and naive FTs doing this and other crazy things. Real snivelling, grovelling weasels, of which there are far too many here in China! By contrast, Chinese teachers would never teach gratis!

As for training centers, I have worked for two. I worked for the first one for spite to rile the public college I was working for because the FAO there was delaying the signature of my contract. I had moved to that city a few days before the teaching was due to start, and taught for a fortnight wihout a signed contract. The contract stipulated that I should ask permission before taking on a second job. After signing the contract that was at long last offered me, I asked if I could CONTINUE teaching at the training center! The FAO was furious, but I told him I hadn't broken the contract as it hadn't been signed during the period I had the two jobs! In fact, the job at the training center was a bad job, I hated it for the fortnight I was there! I managed to relinquish it without losing out financially by using the clause in the public contract pertaining to second jobs. Later I heard the FAO at the college called up the training center to ask if I was still teaching there! Sneaky bastard!

MY second job at a training center was for two days, to act as hoiiday relief for the foreign edutainers employed by a training center in Shijiazhuang. My recruiter had begged me to help him out - he had earlier found a job for me in Hengshui at a key senior middle school, though I had an L visa which I was permitted by my employer not to have to change. I felt I owed the recruiter, so I accepted his temporary job offer, though reluctantly as teaching children bores me very much. There was an African-American teaching some children there. I was asked to observe. The boss, Victor, interrupted the lesson a couple of times to shout out to the Chicagoan that the children wouldn't know the English word he was using! So rude. That Saturday and the following Sunday morning I was whizzed across the city from class to class in the bosses wife's car, almost colliding with another car on the way! I was relieved when Victor didn't ask me back the following weekend - maybe my teaching was below par. Thank the Lord!

#23 Parent Terry - 2012-07-25
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

Darker and darker, grimmer and grimmer, gets the picture that you paint. You are putting the wind up me alright. Perhaps I should have tried harder to find a Private English Language Centre to accept me. I have worked for a few learning centres in China, so I know they give you a fair deal and encourage you to speak Mandarin. I have actually spent only one day teaching in a Chinese university, so I'll give way to your greater knowledge, Clyde. You sound like you know what you're talking about to me. It looks like I got it right years ago when I avoided working for universities and state schools.

Time is betraying me, so it looks as if I'll have to start at the dreaded university now, 1 Sept. I will remember what you said though and not teach the leaders' nippers for free. Thank you so much.

#24 Parent Clyde - 2012-07-25
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

It would seem to me obvious that if we all learned Chinese then we would all get along a lot better with our employers. Instead of frosty glances and irritations, we might be able to ganbei it through to the end of our contacts, with grinning leaders patting us on our backs.

There's a much easier and more direct way to make the leaders happy and pat you on the back. First, DON'T learn Mandarin. It's not necessary. Better to be the smiling, gullible, stupid foreigner. Then they'll love you. Do any favors they ask you. Tutor their friends children. Go teach at their friend's private school on weekends for peanuts. Do extra work. Flatter them. Then they will love you.

Basically, they love a chump. Learning Mandarin will only help if you are a chump FIRST. If you are not a chump, learning Mandarin will make you more threatening. They don't care if you appreciate their culture or make the effort to learn the language. Usually they don't give a F___ about China. They care about themselves, and their bank accounts. Let them make some extra money off of you, well, lots of it, while you make some table scraps; let them get face from having you follow them around at their heals, and then they will love you.

But NEVER learn their own language and be independent and competent and a master of their culture. Holy crap is that a recipe for hatred and resentment.

Be a doormat. They love foreign doormats that only stutter in Mandarin.

OK, obviously I'm being a little hyperbolic, but, sadly, my hyperbole is frequently, shockingly, not as ridiculous as the reality in question.

#25 Parent Magister - 2012-07-25
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

we might be able to ganbei it through to the end of our contacts

Now that's an entirely different matter again but one I can certainly get on board with :-)

#26 Parent Terry - 2012-07-25
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

Yes I know you didn't call me a GW, and I'm sorry if you thought I went off of the point. I did possible throw in an extra ingredient or so.

It would seem to me obvious that if we all learned Chinese then we would all get along a lot better with our employers. Instead of frosty glances and irritations, we might be able to ganbei it through to the end of our contacts, with grinning leaders patting us on our backs. All this learning Mandarin would of course be very time-consuming......but we must do something in our free time.

#27 Parent Dragonized - 2012-07-24
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

I'm glad we cleared the misunderstanding. I have to say it's rare on this board to have a disagreement come to good ends with both sides respecting each other for the better. I am happy this happened today.

#28 Parent Clyde - 2012-07-24
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

Thanks for that elucidation Dragonized. I think I was conflating what you said with some of the much more over-the-top assertions of another poster. Absolutely, white women are going to have a much less difficult time in China than black women. It is also possible, as you mentioned, that some may be shielded from a more direct confrontation with certain of the harsher realities. So, though, could some Western men in China, though for very different reasons.

Anyway, after reading your carefully written response to what I'd written before, I think I misread what you'd originally written. Though, because you hadn't supposed the context it wouldn't be too difficult to misinterpret the context.

In any case, I think you cleared things up and I'm glad I was well off the mark in thinking you were expressing a general hatred of women. This is an instance where I'm very pleased to be wrong!

I still maintain that my experience with foreign women overseas as been a bit different. Maybe I was a bit lucky, but I can think of 3 Western women who were really great people to work with and to know. Others perhaps weren't so stellar, but weren't bad. I have to work to think of bad examples, and I can only come up with one, because she got a bit of power and it went to her head. But the guy who replaced here was much, much worse.

I think no matter how wide our circles might be while teaching overseas, we can't possibly have a thorough appreciation of the other gender also working overseas. Really, what percentage of them can we possibly know?

Lastly, as I've hinted at above, I've seem more good female foreign teachers than male, though, of course, as a male myself, I know men can be among the best.

Cheers, and sorry for overreacting to your post.

#29 Parent Dragonized - 2012-07-24
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

Clyde, I think you took what I said way out of context. I don't hate or have animosity towards western women from the country that I am a citizen of. As a matter of fact, I adored the women growing up and thought the world of them. When you are in love with the idea of something, you will generally see past its faults. But going abroad allows you to make more comparisons.

It was working overseas and dealing with characters from all sorts of backgrounds across all genders that made me change my views slightly when it comes to certain groups. If I am living in the United States of America, England, or Australia I wouldn't categorize the western women as always being a certain way. But I did see how working overseas, being White, and being a Native Speaker all at the same time gave the western women the better chances of not experiencing as much negativity compared to what I went through as well as what others went through.

When you have less negative experience, you may keep a little bit of that bubble of everything being and going towards the better and it's easier to self rationalize the world as still being an optimistic, idealistic place to be in. Being deprived (if that's the correct word) of the truly bad experiences such as being out in the street with little money, being insulted personally by a student, being discriminated against in all walks of life, etc. you will not understand how reality can be much worse than how you see it. I just think the women I have met overseas came across as a little jaded sometimes, though not all were.

As for the disagreement over whether the system works or doesn't work in their favor, I was speaking from a perspective based out of ethnic definitions. Compared to, say, African American Women who work as ESL English Teachers in China (yes I have also worked with them) I would say the White Western Women has huge advantages. Just by applying for any ESL job I am sure they will get more responses per person than people defined as ethnic minorities in Western Countries.

I have also personally posted about how I heard of Chinese Bosses who had attempted rape on some of the female foreign teachers (this information I obtained from the Silverboy poster from something he had written a couple of years back) and how despicable that was. I am well aware there are 2 sides to every coin.

I think you contributed some very useful information regarding why we shouldn't come teach in China. However don't tell me I "hate" someone just because they belong to a certain, defined group. My personal resentment for some of the western women I have met come from personal experience including receiving opinions which come from an attitude of baseless arrogance. "Western Women" can also include women such as Japanese American, Pakastani British, Chinese Australian, etc. and I wouldn't necessarily want to deal with them any more than the western women I had met overseas. Maybe I wasn't specific enough, but let's be more modest, eh?

#30 Parent Clyde - 2012-07-24
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

am 1.70 cms tall and weigh 70 kilos, not exactly the poster child of obesity, and I have been called "fat."

Yap. Me too. I'm about the same weight. Chinese, as will everyone, zero in on any imperfection. They are just much more open about talking about it. Of course to your face they will say you are handsome, and this really goes to the heads of some foreign men, but to each other they will point out anything at all wrong.

After reading some of the poster's comments about Western women, I'm starting to think that as much as they have to worry about the Chinese perception of them, there may be some or many male expats who speak much more negatively about them.

Oh well.

#31 Parent Clyde - 2012-07-24
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

Actually, foreign teachers of Oral English are highly valuable in China for exactly the purpose we were hired for, which is to help students to SPEAK English. Consistently, I have found that my best students at the university I worked at were the ones who had had a foreign teacher before some time in their education. The difference was very conspicuous. That is testimony enough. Further, I've seen students make exceptional progress in training schools I've worked at, if they were lucky enough to get moderately good teachers.

#32 Parent Magister - 2012-07-24
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

Once again your reply to me seems to be based on a slightly different topic to the one I posted. In the circumstances you described then yes an employer would have every right to be "miffed" about an employee lying about their qualifications. However this is not the point that you originally made (and which you make again in the above post) which was much more along the lines of if we all learn Chinese then we'll get along better with our employers. This is what I responded to and I did it without calling you a GW, etc.

#33 Parent Magister - 2012-07-24
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

Yes. More students at a higher price per class. Not sure that education has much to do with it, more the value of a white face.

#34 Parent San Migs - 2012-07-24
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

But let's face it, teaching oral English for 48 clock hours a month for 5,000 Yuan, accommodation rent-free, with a Chinese teaching assistant helping you prepare 1 lesson /week and assisting you in class is a walk in the park for a relatively high pay in a county where a barber earns just 800 Yuan a month. You name me another country where I can get a better deal than that. I BET YOU CAN'T!

@ BW: I have just read your post and I can't disagree with it,not at all.

Except for this part. 5,000 yuan a month even if you save all of it, is nothing outside of China, nothing at all.

If you plan on staying in China long term, sure you can save, but be aware many Chinese are earning and saving far more. FT's salaries in the public sector are static, while chinese teachers salaries are increasing.

God forbid you had to move home, that money may not be as good as you think. Just my two mao....

Peace
SMGS

#35 Parent Terry - 2012-07-24
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

If one of the required qualifications for a particular English teaching job in China is fluency in Mandarin and you arrive unable to speak a word of the language then the leaders should be miffed and you should get the sack.

It's not up to us as to what should or should not be a prerequisite for employment in China, should or shouldn't be just doesn't come into it. I personally do not believe that most English teaching jobs in China will ever demand any knowledge of Chinese.

I don't know what the all the brouhaha is all about, all I suggested was, if you want to try and get on with[very difficult] people [leaders] then it would be good to learn Mandarin. The next thing I know is that I get weird replies, something like "another GW has emerged from the slime again"(something like that)

#36 Parent Clyde - 2012-07-24
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

I have personally met, conversed with, and gotten to know personally western women traveling and working in all 3 countries I have worked at as an ESL English Teacher, and I can pretty much say many of these girls think the world revolves around them. They will eat up all of your time and use you as company they can just "dump" on with their extravagent and "wonderous" ideas of what they think the world is like. Most will never have the courage to speak out against the injustices that goes on in whatever society they are currently living and working in, and for that matter why would they? The world's system is rigged in their favor for the most part, for they are always given more leniency and cared for than most of their peers.

Wow! I have had the exact opposite experience, and also in three countries. I've met some great Western women in all three countries. They could also be outspoken politically and would easily stand up for their beliefs. What's going on? Why is there so much resentment towards Western women? It makes me wonder if some posters got along with women in their own countries before they moved over seas. I've always got along well with the fairer sex, but some males do not.

The idea that "the system is rigged in [women's] favor" is, pardon my saying it, just adding insult to injury. Be logical about it. People generally put themselves first, and they rig the system to benefit themselves, not people who are conspicuously different. I think you will agree that men have maintained the reigns of power in most places and at most times. They have used that power to benefit themselves at the expense of women (see "China"), which is logical and probably inevitable until we evolve more as a species (socially and in terms of consciousness, I don't mean we need to grow antennae). Women historically have gotten less pay, been subjected to domestic violence (and still are quite a lot in a country I can think of that we all know very well), and have been considered absolutely, innately inferior. There have been laws about what size stick one could beat one's wife with, and in some places a woman can be stoned to death for going out unchaperoned by a man, or improperly dressed. Surely this is not the upper hand. But there are men that resent women and will squarely blame the victim, especially if women don't like them (which, considering some of the people in question, would be a self-fulfilling prophecy for the men). some men may make an exception for underprivileged females in developing countries that can be rented out for the price of a fast food meal in one's home country, but that doesn't count because it's not an equal playing field. That's just the same as liking the staff in a hotel who are paid to be nice to you. If you don't like the women in your own country, you don't like women.

Curiously, some men will want to find a Chinese girlfriend or wife in China, when, just outside their apartment there are thousands of single Chinese women living right there in the West. But those are not desirable, because they can not be had. They are bitches! An exact replica in China, who is much less privileged, is suddenly lovely.

Anyway, I don't know what planet you live on. But, I like women, including Western women. They're great. Lovely people. Generally a bit nicer than men, and, not surprisingly, less dicks. When people start talking about how much they hate women, it's a bad, bad sign (and making an exception for underprivileged females in the developing world just makes it worse, because it's so transparently self-deluding).

I presume overt racism (other than saying one can have any Chinese girl they want) is not tolerated on this board, but why is overt sexism, chauvinism, and open misogyny tolerated?

Must be that there are a lot of like-minded women-haters on the board, and anyone who stands up for women, and women themselves, are alienated and bullied. That would be my guess. Hopefully I'm wrong!

#37 Parent juanisaac - 2012-07-24
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

I agree with you about how people point at foreign, overweight woman. I worked with a couple in a city in northern Jiangsu for two weeks. Both these women were from the states and here doing teacher training. One was a nice looking, but overweight blonde woman. The other was her mother. When women saw them, they just stared at them all day. Even the vice-principal of the college they were working at when he compared them to Chinese woman told them they were fat and CHinese women skinny.

During breakfast at our hotel, one woman while she opened her mouth up and down like a horse, just kept staring at the women. It seems women are in competition with eachother for beauty in China, and foreign women as "I am glad I am not them."

I am 1.70 cms tall and weigh 70 kilos, not exactly the poster child of obesity, and I have been called "fat."

#38 Parent juanisaac - 2012-07-24
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

True, we foreigners are expendable luxury. But may you consider that we are also an investment, albiet exploited, by the school administration to show parents. At one teacher training I had, one teacher that her school had three foreign teachers to appear as important bastion of education. So I guess anything that can bring more students through the doors is all we are used for.

#39 Parent Clyde - 2012-07-24
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

It's also worth noting that some schools (particularly training centres) would actually prefer to employ newbies with little or no language or cultural experience of china (easier to control). By in large the management of such places are not looking to become friends or extend cultural ties, what they are looking to do is make money. Do that for them and you'll generally find that you have a more pleasant experience working for them regardless of your ability to speak mandarin.

This is spot on. After working for training schools for about 2 years, and having outstanding recommendations, as well as a legit TEFL and an advanced degree, and also having the right sort of look and temperament that is considered desirable, I found nobody was interested in hiring me. Why? I knew the ropes and couldn't be cheated. What they really want is a young person just out of college who they can manipulate, and will be smiling and stupid while getting cheated because they just don't know any better. When foreigners first arrive in China to teach, they are like baby sea turtles just hatched from the eggs and trying to make it to the see. Those turtles can be eaten by gulls, crabs, and then once in the water sharks. The idea of the training schools is to get such green and tender foreigners, in China for the first time, filled with good intentions, and then cut them raw deals right away and get their signatures on it. Cheating the new teacher is more important than having a reliable good teacher, so shortsighted are the predatory capitalistic "communist" businessmen.

I remember telling one such bosshole that I didn't need help opening a bank account, as I'd just done it on my own using Mandarin. He scowled. Why? Because there was a "favor" he couldn't hold over me. I did it myself. Better to not speak any Mandarin and be completely at the mercy of the school, and completely dependent on them. The last thing many of these schools want is a competent, independent, acclimated foreigner. They want a virgin, so to speak, and not a seasoned whore, so to speak.

I remember actually considering taking teaching experience OFF of my resume and replacing it with unrelated office work type stuff, just to disguise the fact that I know the situation on the ground and couldn't be taken advantage of left, right, and center.

Universities, on the other hand, all wanted to hire me, but they almost all wanted to cheat me as well, except for the ones in really remote areas with really severe winters and heavy isolation, because they were so desperate they were willing to supply the standard government contract without tinkering with it so that they personally benefited from the personal losses they'd cleverly arranged for me.

#40 Parent Dragonized - 2012-07-23
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

I'm going to assume you haven't read the posts made by the londongirl person from a recent discussion thread regarding working conditions at a franchised English First branch located in China. But what you said about Western women is pretty off target to say the least. I have personally met, conversed with, and gotten to know personally western women traveling and working in all 3 countries I have worked at as an ESL English Teacher, and I can pretty much say many of these girls think the world revolves around them. They will eat up all of your time and use you as company they can just "dump" on with their extravagent and "wonderous" ideas of what they think the world is like. Most will never have the courage to speak out against the injustices that goes on in whatever society they are currently living and working in, and for that matter why would they? The world's system is rigged in their favor for the most part, for they are always given more leniency and cared for than most of their peers.

If I had to choose a group of people whom to have sympathy for, it would have to always be a few of the non-White teachers who work in Asia. But honestly western women are not "ignored" by the expat population. That's all.

#41 Parent The Bully Wee - 2012-07-23
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

I don't feel at all sorry for Western women teaching in China. If they are blonde, that's a big plus. Slim is good too, but overweight isn't bad. Overweight women back home are discriminated against, but less so in China. How many Western women come on these boards to complain? Very very few!

In Shanxi I worked for a Chinese agent who seconded me to senior middle schools. He told me the senior middle schools almost always accepted a female Westerner before a male Westerner. I've seen Western women become very popular with their bosses and with students in China. As for street manners by locals to foreigners, they can be very bad! But let's face it, teaching oral English for 48 clock hours a month for 5,000 Yuan, accommodation rent-free, with a Chinese teaching assistant helping you prepare 1 lesson /week and assisting you in class is a walk in the park for a relatively high pay in a county where a barber earns just 800 Yuan a month. You name me another country where I can get a better deal than that. I BET YOU CAN'T!

I don't wanna work hard for a living, and I don't wanna be poor. China is ideal for me!

#42 Parent Magister - 2012-07-23
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

Some other poster, Magister, I believe, said, being able to speak mandarin shouldn't be a prerequisite for the job; I never said it should be

What I actually said is that speaking mandarin shouldn't be a prerequisite for fair treatment by your employer (do you disagree with this?). That was in response to your comment that suggested foreign teachers bring problems on themselves by not speaking the language.

There are many reasons for learning Chinese and as a topic of debate this has been covered many times over the existence of this board including several times in the last couple of months. However, learning the language to avoid contempt from Chinese colleagues (as you stated in your original post) hardly seems a good reason. Nor do I think that it would be particularly effective at solving poor relationships between foreign teachers and local management because the reasons for this contempt generally run far deeper than just the chinese language skills of the ft. It's also worth noting that some schools (particularly training centres) would actually prefer to employ newbies with little or no language or cultural experience of china (easier to control). By in large the management of such places are not looking to become friends or extend cultural ties, what they are looking to do is make money. Do that for them and you'll generally find that you have a more pleasant experience working for them regardless of your ability to speak mandarin.

#43 Parent Clyde - 2012-07-23
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

I have received flak on these boards for complaining of chinese teachers receiving benefits that I did not get, and was called greedy and stupid for complaining about it, but I don't see it as complaining, merely standing up for myself.

I agree, and what's particularly insulting is that foreigners in some public institutions, such as universities, are now paid less than equally qualified Chinese teachers BECAUSE they are foreigners. Where I worked I discovered this and refused to work for less than my Chinese peers because I was a foreigner. Basically I refused to be treated as an inferior and discriminated against. Really, how can a foreigner live on less than a Chinese counterpart in the developing world? I told them if they didn't match the Chinese teacher's salaries I'd put in a one month notice of leaving. In the end they DID give me the raise, but the English Department didn't appreciate that one bit, and I'm pretty sure they hated me after that. I was accused of being arrogant, but in their own myopic world vision, they couldn't project enough to see that I was only asking for the absolute minimal standards that wouldn't be an arrogant slap in the face. In short, they were so arrogant that they didn't even know they were arrogant.

Why is it selfish to not want to be discriminated against and cheated? If you ask any Chinese teacher if they'd like to go work in a country with a lower salary, and get paid less than the locals, they will all think that would be unfair and they wouldn't do it.

To make matters worse, while getting paid less (this is just starting in unis, not private schools), one is still resented openly for making more money and being spoiled because a decade ago foreign teachers made double what Chinese teachers did. You get the worst of both worlds, the short end of the stick and resentment for getting the long end.

Personally, I think China got worse in the last few years. Just 2 years ago I was planning to stay for the long haul. Then shit started to pile up and stink to wear I just couldn't stand it anymore.

#44 Parent Clyde - 2012-07-23
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

I think you have sized up the leaders very well indeed; however, we shouldn't expect them to change because we deign to teach in China. Some other poster, Magister, I believe, said, being able to speak mandarin shouldn't be a prerequisite for the job; I never said it should be, but this is up to the people who control the schools, the Chinese.

Yeah, I really tried to learn Chinese. Sometimes I'd practice for 2-3 hours a day for weeks on end. I had scores of books and programs. But Chinese and I just don't mix well. I found the more I learned the more confusing it got, because they just re-use the same words over and over, and they are all usually one or two syllables.

Anyway, whoever thinks that knowing Mandarin to teach Oral English should be a prerequisite would be very lonely in China, as so few people could learn Mandarin passably, especially to work on a salary equivalent to working in fast food in their homeland. Besides, one doesn't need it to teach Oral English.

Lastly, uh, my Chinese was pretty good, actually, but that didn't help really with leaders. Well, the president of the university liked me, but other leaders saw me as "arrogant" and as a "threat." First of all, they have no choice about having foreigners or not. All public unis are required by the government to have foreigners. But that really mucks up with the hierarchy. Let's say someone is in a position of power more because of connections than ability. A foreigner can size up his English ability in less than a minute. The foreigners are generally the experts at English, which subverts the power structure.

Quick story. Once I was helping a student with a speech. She'd written, "My mother together with me went to…" I told her we wouldn't say that, we'd just say, "My mother and I went to…" and add "together" at the end of the sentence optionally. Anyway, I wrote a correction on the paper. Some leader then told her I was "wrong." Wanker. My textbook was filled with such atrocious grammatical errors I couldn't use it, because it would reinforce the student's "Chinglish". Funny thing is the Chinese, some of them, think they can speak/write English better than we can. those books could have been easily fixed by just about any half-educated foreigner.

Also, knowing Chinese and Chinese culture can make one more of a threat and a nuisance to the leaders. Generally, green teachers are preferred, as long as they have the right look and some credentials. For one they can be cheated.

That said, there are tons of wonderful people in China, it's just that the institutions are going down the toilet, an the once safe haven of public institutions has now been poisoned and they are trying the same sorts of schemes one used to only see in private businesses.

#45 Parent Clyde - 2012-07-23
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

I think the contempt shown by "leaders" is not solely towards foreign teachers but also towards local staff as well.

True. Their treatment of each other is shocking! I'd say in the last few years there has been a change and now foreign teachers are starting to be treated the same or worse than Chinese teachers. For example, foreigners used to teach 12-14 hours a week back in the heyday of working for unis. Now the absolute minimum at most unis is 16, but I often see hours toppling 20. Beyond that they are now writing in all sorts of extra-curricular, unpaid activities into the contract: English Corners; judging events; putting on events (I've seen contracts stipulating, vaguely, "Halloween," "Christmas"); library time; movie night; drama club; and "thesis adviser"). At the same time I've met Chinese teachers teaching as little as 10 hours a week. Thus, it is now possible to be paid less than one's Chines colleagues, while also working more paid hours, AND having a slew of unpaid extra work. The only benefit one gets at this point that the Chinese don't is a pointy hat that says, "CHUMP" on it.

I'm sure there are still good jobs out there, but, last time I looked I finally gave up. The standard contracts of 4 years ago are very difficult to find anymore. Summer vacations have been cut out, more hours have been added, and all the extra bullshit. This may have something to do with the economic crisis and China vying for GDP #1 in a 2nd Great Leap Forward, this one with cement.

#46 Parent San Migs - 2012-07-23
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

If there is one grpuup of people living here that i really feel sorry for are the western women . They are treated with derision by the Chinese and ignored by the foreign population. I hope no woman reading your post takes anything you say seriously.

I am going to be lenient, but Sboy won't agree with you, western women tend to cause problems in china for western men and make for terrible school bosses.

#47 Parent San Migs - 2012-07-23
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

This became increasingly apparent when the Chinese teachers started making more money than the foreigners, because foreign teachers salaries have been basically frozen for the last 8 years or so. Chinese teacher's salaries have more than doubled in that same time. The foreign teacher is considered just for entertainment, and this is partly a defensive measure because many of the Chinese teachers teach in an outmoded style that the students (in a public institution) will tell you they find very boring and inefficient.

I would agree, this is frustrating, and one reason people who value their future/sanity leave. Even if you have a cushy and great job, this can sour it for you. I have received flak on these boards for complaining of chinese teachers receiving benefits that I did not get, and was called greedy and stupid for complaining about it, but I don't see it as complaining, merely standing up for myself.

One reason many move to a place where they do get the credit, respect and salary they deserve.

#48 Parent Terry - 2012-07-23
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

I agree with most of what you say, Clyde, although maybe I wouldn't agree with how much it should affect one. Oh, one thing I wouldn't agree with you at all about, I think the food is ghastly, unhealthy, inasmuch as it can make you very ill, and is loaded with MSG. No problem, you can cook your own food.

I think you have sized up the leaders very well indeed; however, we shouldn't expect them to change because we deign to teach in China. Some other poster, Magister, I believe, said, being able to speak mandarin shouldn't be a prerequisite for the job; I never said it should be, but this is up to the people who control the schools, the Chinese. They could say 'fat girls only' referring to another post. All I am saying is that if you can chat to these leaders and teachers in their own language, life becomes a lot easier. I don't believe that if you set out to learn Chinese with the sole idea of getting on with people that this should be condemned as sucking up to. I would say it's sensible strategy.

You're a great writer and have given me food for thought.

#49 Parent kevin - 2012-07-23
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

Even though you claim to have lived here in china for years your grasp of the foreigners plight here in china seems to be pretty loose.
Anyone who has lived here for more than a year would know that what clyde has to say has a lot more validity than anything you seem to imagine.
If there is one grpuup of people living here that i really feel sorry for are the western women . They are treated with derision by the Chinese and ignored by the foreign population. I hope no woman reading your post takes anything you say seriously.

#50 Parent Clyde - 2012-07-23
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

Hi "The Bully Wee". You make some good points, but I will have to disagree with you on some points for sure. Overweight women SHOULD come to China to teach you say?! Really?! I've known some overweight women teaching in China, and some not even overweight by their own countries standards. Pretty much everywhere they went people talked about how fat they were. I've seen Chinese people pointing at such women, noting that their thighs touch each other when they walk, and even imitating the way they walk. So, the woman should have very thick skin because she will hear "tai pang" (too fat) everywhere she goes. Actually, any shortcoming or flaw in one's appearance will be duly noted, including by students. Comments that one is beautiful or whatnot should be ignored, as they have not bearing on the reality. I would strongly disagree that it is an advantage to be fat, and therefor stick out even more, as a foreigner in China (especially if you are a woman, and will be subjected to highly critical competitive glances from other women). I would HIGHLY disagree that overweight woman are respected in a Patriarchal society in which average women often get around in ridiculously high-heels and short shorts to compete with sex-workers and hold on to their husband's attention.

Sadly, I know of one overweight woman who was refused a job specifically because she was "too fat." They told her so. No, it is not desirable to be a foreign overweight woman, when is is absolutely undesirable to be a Chinese overweight woman. And what will this woman's chances be of meeting a suitable Chinese man?

Further, when applying for the same job as a more qualified female colleague, I was offered much more money. So, I will have to disagree again that females are preferred over males in schools, or at least higher education. I would also disagree that students are more comfortable with female teachers. This is on a person to person basis, respective of personality, sense of humor…

Personally, if I ran a school, I'd prefer to hire women over men for some of the reasons you mentioned, but in the long run it's a person by person game, and I'd want the best and most able people, which depends not on gender.

Cheers

#51 Parent Clyde - 2012-07-23
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

Hi Terry:

Yes, I made a very concerted effort to learn Chinese, even before I arrived. I kept it up throughout my time in China, but, alas, never got very good because it's really a bastard of a language. I got some recognition for basically knowing how to speak, but, the disrespect for foreigners runs much deeper than that, I think. First and foremost is the hierarchy, which is all important. It took me years to appreciate the full horror of the hierarchy. In that hierarchy you are nothing. This became increasingly apparent when the Chinese teachers started making more money than the foreigners, because foreign teachers salaries have been basically frozen for the last 8 years or so. Chinese teacher's salaries have more than doubled in that same time. The foreign teacher is considered just for entertainment, and this is partly a defensive measure because many of the Chinese teachers teach in an outmoded style that the students (in a public institution) will tell you they find very boring and inefficient.

The problem with the "leaders" (note their use of this word where we might use "manager" or "administrator"…), is, frankly, they believe they are absolutely superior to those beneath them. No matter what your degree, age, work experience, knowledge, or what have you, you are beneath them. This is a problem because in reality, you are NOT just a rookie teacher who graduated from a Chinese university like all the others. You may come with much more education and knowledge, and you may, in the big picture, in every respect, be superior to your leaders. In the West we don't enforce hierarchies like they do in China. If you are insufficiently deferential (as opposed to pleasantly neutral), and do not show/acknowledge your subservience in the hierarchy, you are seen as rude. In short you need to bow and scrape and do favors for any lackey "leader" who has been promoted to a position higher than you, and of course you are at the absolute bottom. In order to punish the "rude" teachers who behave as equals instead of subservient wretches, the "leaders" may exercise arbitrary and capricious displays of power to frustrate you, including non-cooperation, or deliberate with-holding of needed information, documents, and even money.

As for the rudeness on the streets. That's really a newer phenomenon, which was the worst this year than at any time before. In more first hear in China I heard "F___ you" only ONCE! But in my last year, it could easily be a few times a day. This also has a lot to do with location. I don't hear it in 2nd tier cities. You need to be 3rd tier for this particular treatment. Also, I was hearing it a lot because I was in an area with tons of school boys, who are the worse offenders, and almost the only offenders (some adult males also can be dicks, not surprisingly).

Among the benefits of living in China are: wonderful students (if you teach in a public university), mostly friendly people (the rude ones are a growing nasty exception), excellent and cheap food, the ability to really immerse yourself in another country, and if you are lucky a relatively cushy job.

#52 Parent Clyde - 2012-07-23
And a couple more things

I want to add a couple more things to the list.

    Mindboggling cheapness that would make Ebeneezer Scrooge cringe: Yes, there is a notion, I believe, that Chinese people have of getting ahead at any cost, and worry about the details later. This often shows up in really short-sited business models. For example, lets say a fruit seller sees you walking past every day. One day you stop to buy fruit. They overcharge you ridiculously. You never buy from them again, instead of making them your regular seller. I worked in a school where they refused to buy new erasers for the chalkboards and used rags instead. So I bought my own, and wrote my name on them in permanent marker so I'd at least have an eraser for my classes. They removed my name with solvent. Those erasers, at the time, cost me less than 2 yuan each. They will ask you to return a 30 yuan book at the end of the term. There is no bottom to what is not worth being cheap about. When I lived in the States, anything under a quarter I wouldn't worry about, for example. But they will worry about 1 stinking yuan, or even a jiao. Rich bosses will refuse to spend miniscule amounts of money out of this extraordinary, stupid, cheapness.

    Arbitrary displays of power!
It took me years to understand this, and I only got a good grasp of it on the tail end, as I plotted and schemed and finally managed to extricate myself from China without getting screwed on the way out, or at least getting my mind F-d with, and reminded who were the leaders and who was a foreign pile of shit. As I said before, hierarchy is everything (which is also why any asshole in a black sedan will honk at you like you are a pig in the road when you are actually crossing the street, in a crosswalk, when the light is yours), but power used correctly is invisible. Only the misuse of power is conspicuous. This is similar to "kindness." I was once told by a martial arts instructor to be careful because people might mistake my kindness for "weakness." In the same way, if a "leader" does his/her job properly, he or she should be helping and facilitating those beneath him or her. But this could be seen as weakness, and really, Chinese leaders want to display power.

The best way to show power is by being an asshole and getting away with it (like honking ferociously at innocent pedestrians). For example, a boss will show up 20-30 minutes late to a dinner to show he is the most powerful. What an ass. We'd just think that person was a dick in the West. Well, this same mentality can be seen in the daily management of schools. I always wondered why I'd get my schedule of classes the night before classes started. Surely they'd want me to do a good job of teaching, in which case I'd need to make preparations. Could they be so incompetent that they just procrastinated until the last minute? One place where I worked always gave us our schedules, including what classes and subjects we'd teach, one or two days before the term started. We'd all complain and they knew very well that this stressed us out, and they'd promise this wouldn't happen again, but every term it happened again. One time I got my boss to make a call and get me my schedule 2 days before classes started, but nobody told the person that normally gives it to me. He waited until after 10 pm the night before classes started to offer me the schedule, which made me aware the holding on to it until the last minute was deliberate (they did it even if the schedule was ready days before).

So, why do this? Why compromise the teacher's ability to teach, and the students education in the process? Because it's an arbitrary show of power. It is done merely to piss off the teachers and remind them who has the power. Sounds incredibly petty, and it's hard to believe anyone can be so petty. But it's also hard to believe someone would brazenly walk to the front of the line and cut in front of you. The more petty and childish the display of power, the more powerful it is, because it makes you fully aware that it's ridiculous, and there's NOTHING you can do about it. (Unless of course you are smarter than they are, in which case you could coincidentally succumb to illness on the first few days of class, etc. But who wants to play those childish games.)

The two things above are probably the main reason I'm not in China anymore.

#53 Parent San Migs - 2012-07-23
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

Another appeaser/GW comes out of the woodwork!

#54 Parent Magister - 2012-07-23
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

But overweight Western females are actually respected, and receive better treatment.

As a slim white male I don't really agree with that.

The first problem that larger ladies might come across is that Chinese people on the street will often call it as they see it, so as a bigger woman you may well get called fat (pang胖)or strong (zhuang壮)to your face. Of course what we westerners and the Chinese consider as overweight is not the same. A western girl with what we might call curves would likely be considered fat in this country. Finally your comments about body shape and the perceived wealth that is associated with a larger figure might be true for older generations within china who had to live through times of hardship when appearance took a backseat to survival but such attitudes don't persist in modern china with younger generations. Young Chinese woman spend just as much time, money and energy on maintaining their ideal body shape (resembling a 12 year old boy) as western women do and are equally just as bitchy towards those who don't meet the ideal.

In general you have to remember that china is by in large a patriarchal society (I'm aware there are examples of matriarchal societies in the western provinces and Tibet). Particularly away from the big modern cities, china's social development is a longway behind that of the west and therefore opportunities for local women can be limited. I'm frequently bemused by the attitude of both Chinese males and females as to the role of women within the home and society at large. To me it seems like something out of a Jane Austen novel.

#55 Parent Magister - 2012-07-23
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

I think the contempt shown by "leaders" is not solely towards foreign teachers but also towards local staff as well. The working conditions in china are generally poor and the way that management treats employees would often be seen as unacceptable if you were to compare any industry in china with the equivalent in the west. Perhaps the contempt towards foreign staff appears more evident because we often expect better treatment having just arrived from countries where it's the norm. Local staff on the other hand are often happy to lie down and take it as they've never experienced anything different. Of course you could argue that we as foreigners often do receive better treatment than locals in terms of wages, benefits and working hours which in itself contributes toward the contempt.

I fully agree with silverboy that learning Chinese should not be a prerequisite to being treated fairly by an employer who has employed you primarily on the basis of you being an English speaker. However, I do concede that in reality learning the language has many benefits for an individual.

#56 Parent The Bully Wee - 2012-07-22
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

Not for you, teaching in China, that is. You are a male, but how about Western females? I'd say from a female FT's perspective the dirt, pollution and the interaction with local people in the street may well be more problematic, especially the staring. But overweight Western females are actually respected, and receive better treatment. The local logic is that they must be rich because they are fat, and therefore are looked up to!
At work, female Western foreign teachers are better treated, by students, who will be less inhibited than they will be with Western male foreign teachers. The Chinese staffs know that many are non-smokers, won't get pissed and behave ignorantly, and won't flirt with beautiful Chinese students nor visit whorehouses, which Western men may well do. Also, the female Chinese teachers of English won't feel inhibited about befriending them. In contrast, said Chinese won't befriend Western males. They are well aware that can cause malicious gossip!
Western females who can bear bad street manners and dirty surtoundings should come to China for teaching. the Chinese education providers actually prefer them, as do many Chinese students.
As for me, I'm a Western male who has lived and taught happily in China for many a year. Horses for courses, as it were!

#57 Parent Terry - 2012-07-22
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

Fair enough, you did state that you were going to focus on the reasons not to go to China. I'm surprised you did concede that there were good reasons. How can good reasons survive inside that picture you portray? I anxiously await part 2, to find out.

You have made me reconsider whether or not to return to China because you have vividly reminded me what things were really like, I'd actually forgotten. However, when I think about it, my experience of China was a little different in a couple of respects. I never felt a welling up of hostility towards me on the streets, or was aware of any nasty remarks made by passing strangers aimed in my direction.

As for the veiled contempt shown by leaders in the workplace; do you feel that many of us bring this contempt upon ourselves by not making an effort to learn a word of Mandarin? If you spend five years in China(or even one) shouldn't you(not you personally) be able to hold some sort of conversation in the language? Many of us can't. If I were Chinese I might well find such an inability to make an effort somewhat annoying.

Hell of a lot of truth in what you say though.

#58 Parent San Migs - 2012-07-22
Re: Why you should think twice about teaching in China

Clyde, I cannot find anything to disagree with in anything you wrote.

Regarding the internet, yes it is frustrating and irritating, paying for and opening a vpn just to access websites that the rest of the world can access easily. There is not the internet like in the west, merely, a walled garden.

As for how schools treat you, at best you will be an expendable luxury, worst, treated as a nuisance and pain to them. Very hard people to read, and they can pull off the friendly, smiley act very well.

Regards
San Migs

Clyde - 2012-07-22
Why you should think twice about teaching in China

I worked in China for close to 5 years, and at 3 different schools, including 2 private schools and a public university. After leaving and relocating in another country, it's become obvious how much I put up with that I don't have to put up with at all any more, and why in general I would NOT recommend China to new teachers. There are good reasons to go to China, and I wouldn't have stayed there so long if I didn't find a lot of them, but here I am just going to focus on the reasons why NOT to.

Serious Reasons Why You Shouldn't Go To China To Teach

[My experience was in 2 small cities, and one's experience might be different in a very large city.]

    The Pollution. As everyone knows, China has many of the most polluted cities in the world, and the levels of pollution can be somewhere between apocalyptic and purgatorial. Not only is there the longer range risk of cancer, but many have immediate reactions, including persistent coughing that plagues them until they leave the city in question or China altogether. Also compromises the immune system and opens one up to serious lung infections.

    The Internet. If you like your internet, you can kiss it goodbye. No more Youtube videos. No more Facebook. No more anything that has the word "blog" in it. No "Wordpress," no "twitter". Worse, recently if I accidentally clicked on an image, say in Google image search (which works like shit in China) and it went to a "blog" page, I would be retroactively punished. My internet would hang or all links wouldn't work until I disabled and re-enabled the internet. If you live in a public school, as you typically will if you work for one, and you get their internet, the speeds can be nostalgic, reminding you of the old 28.8 external modems on a bad day, or worse.

    Illness.Who wants to get a bunch of month long colds and serious lung infections. This becomes normal in China, especially if you are teaching children. Seriously, be prepared to use more tissue and hawk up more goobers in one year than you would normally in a decade. Chinese use antibiotics for the common cold, so they have developed super-strains of antibiotic resistant colds. If you get a normal cold that lasts a week, you are blessed. Most end up being respiratory infections. I shit you not, you will be spitting green loogies and chocking them down while trying to teach. If you can't stand having a bad cold, China is bad, bad news.

    Restrooms.The worst restrooms I've seen anywhere in the world. A typical restroom, say at a bus station or in a university, will not have doors (in case you like your privacy). There will be no toilet paper. Hot water?! Don't be ridiculous. Soap? Ha, ha, ha. You must always carry around your own tissue. Hopefully there is water so you can at least rinse your hands. You will see more crap than in your whole life, because these are squat toilets and many, many people don't flush. It may be most people don't, because they expect a cleaner to come in and do it. Because the toilets are the squat variety, the crap just sits there, not even submerged in water. You will see crap like never before, and you can't escape it. Needless to say, the stench from the common WC can be unbearable.

    Corruption. Corruption is so epidemic it's not even seen as corruption. Everyone must cheat everyone else just to counterbalance being cheated themselves. In the hierarchy everyone above you screws you over, as is their birthright, and you in turn must screw over everyone below you so as not to be completely screwed by those above. This kind of corruption is seen as necessity and accepted. For example, it is very common to pay a bribe to get a job!That even applies to a public school teaching job, if you are Chinese. You can't trust the food, the merchandise, anything. Corruption has become not only an accepted way of life, but a necessity. It's absolutely unavoidable and ubiquitous.

    Patriarchy. A rabidly patriarchal society. You may find female taxi-drivers, but generally females are considered absolutely inferior to males. Prostitution is rampant, and a real Chinese man, who is at all involved in business or the public (meetings and meeting with others as regards deals and whatnot) should know how to drink, smoke, and whore. There are tends of millions of boys who will never get married because of the number of aborted female babies. This is not a country for feminists, or humanists. It's great for chauvinists though.

    Cold War Mentality. By this I don't mean a fear of nuclear bombs, and in Russia and the US, but I do mean a general distrust of other countries and foreigners, coupled with an antiquated suspicion of spies. Yes, Chinese people in smaller cities will actually be suspicious of you and think you may be a spy. In order to establish that you are NOT a spy, the government may keep a close eye on you. You may be spied on, ironically, in the name of protecting "our China" from evil spies. In short, you are automatically a suspect, guilty until proven innocent, and subjected to exactly the crime you are suspected of, spying. China has some 40,000 people employed to monitor the internet and email communications. They do keep an eye on you. In general China has an air of "oppression" that one doesn't find in other countries. Let's just say it has a kiss of North Korea about it.

    Spitting.WTF?! Why is it that people in other countries don't need to spit, but Chinese need to spit like mad. It's difficult to hear the stentorian hawking sounds all about one without feeling insulted, because such ambitious spitting is typically meant as a direct insult in the West. If someone were to want to spit at you as an insult, and made a big production of it, they couldn't compete with a completely indifferent spitting in China. People believe the body has 4, or is it 5, fluids in it, and one of them is phlegm. Consequently, they must rid themselves of phlegm. The older folk do this constantly, and it's extremely disgusting. They will spit in a restaurant! There are spittoons strategically placed in restaurants! They will turn their head and spit on the floor in a restaurant! There will be spit on the stairs of your apartment building (not to mention piss). Needless to say, this spitting contributes enormously to the spread of infectious communicable diseases.

    Hygiene.Ba, ha, ha, ha! I already mentioned no soap in the restrooms. I worked in a public university and never saw soap ever in the restrooms, which means the students could never properly wash their hands. In winter the cold water provided would be freezing, so they wouldn't rinse well either if they weren't masochists. Generally, in smaller cities, people behave as if germs didn't exist. If you get a cold it must be your own fault for not wearing "enough layers." There is no disinfecting other than washing dishes, hopefully with dish soap, and most likely cold water. Table tops are usually washed with a damp cloth. Colds and serious respiratory infections are absolutely everywhere. It's a germ bath, worse than riding the New York subway. You are in a Petri dish. Your only hope is to do everything you can to bolster your immune system.

    Traffic. Oh crap! You know the general rule about decent people becoming assholes when they get behind the wheel. In smaller cities Chinese people become "ferocious assholes" behind the wheel. When you are walking, you are shit. When you cross a street, it is very common for cars to speed up at you and lean on the horn to tell you to get the F out of their way, you inferior too-poor-to-show-off-that-you-have-a-car scum. Traffic laws are, what, jokes. Taxis will drive in oncoming traffic and weave all over the place with one hand perpetually honking. See next point.

    Honking. It is glorious to be rich in China, and it is glorious to honk. I don't care if you are the most considerate pedestrian in the world, and you just want to go to the market and get a bag of groceries, mind your own business and go back home. If you have to walk down the streets and cross a few chances are you will be honked at loudly, rudely, and insistently, like you are a diseases cow blocking an ambulance. The honking is extraordinarily rude and insulting. One takes it in stride, of course, but once one's away from it, one can comfortably look back ans say, "Wholly F___ that was unnecessary!"

    Rudeness. First, spitting, honking, cutting in line, pissing in the street, and corruption are not considered rude. Calling you "lao wai" or "wai gruo ren" 24/7 is not considered rude. Taking you picture while you are slurping noodles is not rude. Strangers talking about you loudly in your presence, in Chinese, is not rude. Smoking and talking very loudly in restaurants is not rude. That is normal and one just has to get used to it. However, in the last couple years, perhaps in conjunction with idiot ramped up nationalism, a more overt kind of direct rudeness is blossoming. It is more and more common to hear, in small cities, while walking down the street, "F___ you!" and "F____ your mother!" Chinese will say they don't know what it means. But, they will say it in Chinese as well so there's no question what it means. Honestly, I've personally been subjected to the most racist public treatment I've ever seen of anyone in my life. In a way it's good for one's own cultural awareness to be exposed to this on the receiving end, and then again it just plain sucks. I've heard "F____ you" from complete strangers (usually boys) as many as on 6 different occasions in one day. However, there's little or no risk of injury. it's just insults.

    Being a foreigner. In a smaller city you will be called foreigner all day long, stared at, and talked about in front of you. If you linger on the street a crowd may form around you. You are constantly a center of attention, and a TARGET. If there are 3 or more boys, they are more likely than not to start smirking, and make some stupid comment, which if you understand Chinese might piss you off a bit. Personally, I got sick of being anyone and everyone's convenient target for ridicule.

    Pissing and shitting in the street. One could say that this is itself a reason to not life in a typical small city in China, as well as it IS a reason. One lives over seas in order to experience another culture, and children wearing "split pants" with their genitalia perpetually exposed so they can piss and crap whenever and wherever the need arises is one of the cultural delights of living in small town China. You will see children squatting and puddles forming on the sidewalk under them everywhere. You will even see them crapping. Baby piss is not considered vile, therefore it's not uncommon to find little puddles of baby piss on the stairs of your apartment, and even the occasional little pile of baby poop. The children are really, really cute though!

Jesus, this is exhausting, and I have lots of stuff left to warn about. I better just hit one more big one that directly has an impact on teachers, and is ultimately the real reason I left China, as I was able to endure all the crap above OK.

    Treatment of the foreign teacher. This is ultimately the most important thing, and there is a range of treatment from "decent" to ridiculously indifferent or even maliciously cruel. First I must warn you that just because all the "leaders" (this should be a category in itself) and people who work around you are nice to you (on the surface) and honor you at the occasional (banquet), and they smile and wave when they see you, that doesn't mean they give a shit about you, don't resent your very existence, and aren't quietly scheming to screw you out of money or take advantage of your gullibility. They actually think you are stupid, though they would passionately, vehemently deny that if you ever questioned them. But in Chinese culture, it's nothing to smile at someone you hate, or be nice to someone you can't stand. That's just part of life. Just think of a seasoned salesman. He won't win new customers if he doesn't know how to flatter and be nice, even while hoping to screw you over. Chinese people in any position of power have had to deal with this on both ends of the stick enough that their "kung fu" so to speak, is vastly superior to ours, and we don't even know their fighting. Don't be fooled. Only judge by their actual actions.

    There will be quiet schemes to add classes to your schedule, and definitely to screw you out of any and every benefit you receive. There is a strict hierarchy, and in it you are an outsider, though that has some benefits (like not having to go to their meetings). Screwing over the foreigner is not corruption, it's benefiting the motherland. It's good for "our China." I found recently that every new job I was applying for had one or more schemes to cheat me out of money. Normally this would be a "red flag" but it's so common that one just has to accept it and not get riled. Of course the are going to try to dupe you and pocket the difference. But, eventually, I just had enough of it, and didn't want to work for people who would treat me in such a way, perpetually holding me as inferior, as an outsider, and trying to screw me over if possible.

Well, I wanted to make a small list, but the reasons to not go to China are encyclopedic, as are the reasons for going. I could do a positive companion to this, and even some of these bad things have their good side, in a way, but I want to warn people about some of the more dire things they are quite likely to encounter in mainstream China (things which one may not see at all in neighboring Hong Kong, by the way). The corruption I mentioned permeates all of Asia, and perhaps all of the ESL market, but I think it has a bit more muscle, spit-shined, in China. Some things, like the respiratory infections, absolute crap internet, oh and I forgot to mention the largely impenetrable language barrier, are unique to China.

Lastly, I would highly recommend China as a place to travel!! Living there though, be careful, and consider other countries. Now that I'm gone I'm loving having unprotected internet (so to speak) and being able to breath without a rattle of phlegm in my lungs.

Return to Index › Why you should think twice about teaching in China





Go to another board -