SCHOOLS AND RECRUITERS REVIEWS
Return to Index › Re: Re Beijing Huijia Private School
#1 Parent Maxwell - 2013-03-18
Re: Re Beijing Huijia Private School

That is a great post! Can't disagree at all with any of it!

Be polite to Chinese and you get nowhere, better to be rude and nasty to them.

#2 Parent Dragonized - 2013-02-07
Re: Re Beijing Huijia Private School

The Chinese are there for the taking? And they're being taken for as ride!

I do see this comment has been taken out of context, again.

#3 Parent Dragonized - 2013-02-07
Re: Re Beijing Huijia Private School

Yep, tell them to f&&k off once in a while, you might see them smile at you immediately after and also notice a night and day change in their attitude towards you!

Any civil society would not tolerate the type of rudeness seen everywhere in China. It's the Chinese themselves who are not conscious enough, in other words bu zi jue!

#4 Parent Dragonized - 2013-02-07
Re: Re Beijing Huijia Private School

That's the spirit. Good work if you can get it! Just so long as you don't come back on here complaining how those same gulible Chinese people screwed over a talented hardworking teacher such as yourself.

Tells us more about you than anyone else. But thanks for being frank for once.

#5 Parent Dragonized - 2013-02-07
Re: Re Beijing Huijia Private School

You've really had a lot of fun promoting the idea that non-native teacher's negative posts should be ignored. Considering that businessmen who own private "schools" and training centers in China will purposefully hire a non-native speaker to save money and get away with more employee abuse I have a hard time believing you would not be aware of this, although [edited] you probably never bothered to think of it in the first place.

I can only think that you would think this due to the fact that you yourself worked as a manager of sorts at a business in China, and you didn't like the inconvenience of having miscommunications with teachers who were not from the "appropriate" countries in your words.

I've got some bad news for you, you are just as expendable of an employee as the rest of the expats Native or Non-Native. I'm sure a corrupt, greedy, ruthless Chinese owner would love to have you as the "manager" of their "school" [edited]

#6 Parent San Migs - 2013-02-06
Re: Re Beijing Huijia Private School

What I found was in most parts of China if your tone sounds too meek and gentle you will be subjugated to verbal abuse and an invasion of space by the local Chinese. Being a little tougher in the demeanor will actually get you better customer service by the Chinese

I find that is fairly common all over China. Listen to how chinese speak to the waitresses in a restaurant, no please or thanks, just a barked out command or order. If you are too meek or gentle in your intonation, they will take that kindness as weakness, and you will be hung out to dry. In a mobile phone shop the b**ch behind the counter, even though I was there first, deigned to ignore me to take of a chinese guy who just walked in behind me,and ignored me as though I was a piece of trash that had just blown in from the street. That was not always the case but that is when I learnt my lesson there and then. It is not a culture that rewards the meek and the mild, and no place for a thin skinned westerner. You need not be nice to service staff in China, or, speak to them in a mild and pleasing tone. They are there to serve you, that's it! I roasted her for that, and made sure in no uncertain terms I would not tolerate it happening again. Also taxi drivers can be annoying if you come across as "soft". Again, it is the norms of their culture, and we should not be made to feel bad for speaking as you say.

#7 Parent Dragonized - 2013-02-06
Re: Re Beijing Huijia Private School

No, it's just that the Americans whom you had the misfortune of meeting in china are some of the worst Native English speakers on the planet, that's all. I literally have to change the way I speak to Americans who work in China a lot of the times whereas when I talk to Australian, Brits, Irish, and even Scottish teachers I don't have to make too much of an adjustment.

#8 Parent Dragonized - 2013-02-06
Re: Re Beijing Huijia Private School

What I object to is the numerous posts I've seen written by non-white FT's(mainly Asian)-terribly written posts-bad English-bad attitude- complaining about this or that company; and the response that usually follows from seasoned posters is one of whole-hearted support and total belief that they have been given the absolute truth about the behaviour of the evil school. I don't believe that every complaining poster who gives it the 'blue-eyed gets better treatment bit' should be given unquestioned support....It could be that some of them are just trouble-making losers, as are some white blue-eyed FT's.

Whether we choose to give support is up to us. I know for a fact that Asian non-native speakers are treated like crap by most employers and are subjugated to the same abuse as the other foreign ft's. Your statement merely went on a logical round-a-bout and went back to the beginning.

As for smiling and speaking Chinese, I smile all the time to Chinese folks and I speak fluent Mandarin. What I found was in most parts of China if your tone sounds too meek and gentle you will be subjugated to verbal abuse and an invasion of space by the local Chinese. Being a little tougher in the demeanor will actually get you better customer service by the Chinese. Also don't forget your face, the Chinese will treat you differently that say a Philippino or a Western teacher who is ethnically East Asian.

#9 Parent ASTF - 2013-02-06
Re: Re Beijing Huijia Private School

Oh I imagine they'll soon adapt dickens to include a few acronyms for the text message generation. Something along the lines of

It was the BOT
It was the WOT

#10 Parent Mancunian - 2013-02-05
Re: Re Beijing Huijia Private School

That's the spirit. Good work if you can get it! Just so long as you don't come back on here complaining how those same gulible Chinese people screwed over a talented hardworking teacher such as yourself.

Hahaha, no disrespect meant to the poster you answered, but I thought you gave a very talented reply, in just a line and a half- classy, I admire that- you don't get that from the pen of a non-native speaker...unless it's a quote.

Going off on a tangent; this hahaha or hehehe, I used to shy away from, thinking it was very Chinese; until I re-read some Dickens that is-nothing new on the face of the earth; but anyway, what's good enough for the great man, will do me. It'll ruin my day if I read a bit farther and discover he was also into acronyms. Cheers.

#11 Parent ASTF - 2013-02-05
Re: Re Beijing Huijia Private School

That's the spirit. Good work if you can get it! Just so long as you don't come back on here complaining how those same gulible Chinese people screwed over a talented hardworking teacher such as yourself.

#12 Parent Mancunian - 2013-02-05
Re: Re Beijing Huijia Private School

I'm not seeking to American bash but it's my observation that they often don't have such a good knowledge of the idiosyncrasies within the language of other English speaking countries compared to how much say we british are aware of the various everyday idiomatic phrases that are unique to the americans. I think this can probably be put down to the large amount of tv and movies that are produced in the US and then get shipped across the pond.

I used the wrong word actually, didn't I , but you were very tolerant and it just about fits.

Good point you have made- not as if we don't offer them good stuff, like BBC's 'House of Cards,' which is really good but they insist on their own version. Talking about BBC miniseries, we have an American film, albeit with British actors 'Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy' okayish, but not a patch on the aforementioned- how could it be, ten times longer with Alec Guinness.

#13 Parent faker - 2013-02-05
Re: Re Beijing Huijia Private School

Who cares?
The Chinese are there for the taking? And they're being taken for as ride!

#14 Parent ASTF - 2013-02-05
Re: Re Beijing Huijia Private School

However I have sat in on numerous FT's from American, Australia, Scotland ,Canada, and so on, and they all tend to teach good standard English, and the same English. They also know all the different ways of saying

I'm not seeking to American bash but it's my observation that they often don't have such a good knowledge of the idiosyncrasies within the language of other English speaking countries compared to how much say we british are aware of the various everyday idiomatic phrases that are unique to the americans. I think this can probably be put down to the large amount of tv and movies that are produced in the US and then get shipped across the pond.

#15 Parent Mancunian - 2013-02-04
Re: Re Beijing Huijia Private School

However, perhaps it's a little short sighted to say that only native born speakers should be allowed to work as FTs. If you ask any Chinese employee at a foreign trade company who they do business with on a day to day basis they won't just tell you the English, Americans, etc. they say that they speak to Russians, Germans, people from the Middle East and so on and they do it all in English. Dealing with the little foibles of other non-native speakers is a reality that students will have to face if they choose to use their English skills in this way. Therefore is there an argument that they should be exposed to this in the classroom?

Interesting post. I think students will have enough enough to be getting on with being exposed to different accents from the English speaking world without Veladimir Putin sticking his oar in. However I have sat in on numerous FT's from American, Australia, Scotland ,Canada, and so on, and they all tend to teach good standard English, and the same English. They also know all the different ways of saying; and all our expressions, that Veladimir will not know so well. Whether it is car mechanics or a language you should as a student have a good grounding in the standard ways of doing things or saying things before you, in this case, do an extra course so you can speak to the Russians(or hundreds of others) when they speak English. Wherever you go to in the English speaking world, there may very well be a few idiosyncratics-but amazingly, considering the size of the language, it's all pretty much the same-let's keep it that way; and the only way to do that is to only use FT's from appropriate countries.

#16 Parent ASTF - 2013-02-04
Re: Re Beijing Huijia Private School

What I object to is the numerous posts I've seen written by non-white FT's(mainly Asian)-terribly written posts-bad English-bad attitude- complaining about this or that company

Absolutely. If when searching jobs for oral English teachers applicants can't understand that as a bare minimum they will likely need to have good english skills then I feel there is probably something wrong with them in the first place. They should also ask themselves what kind of institution would be looking to hire them without this skill?

Non-native speakers should be particularly wary of accepting a job in a large city in a developed province as these areas can usually attract teachers from the so called 'big 5 countries' and therefore the jobs that are left there are for the rubbish schools who couldn't get the native speakers to begin with. Much better heading to a smaller city or poorer province where they'll be more grateful of getting any FT they can find. However, even then one should be practical about how good a job it's going to be and adjust your expectations accordingly given that you may not have all the necessary skills.

However, perhaps it's a little short sighted to say that only native born speakers should be allowed to work as FTs. If you ask any Chinese employee at a foreign trade company who they do business with on a day to day basis they won't just tell you the English, Americans, etc. they say that they speak to Russians, Germans, people from the Middle East and so on and they do it all in English. Dealing with the little foibles of other non-native speakers is a reality that students will have to face if they choose to use their English skills in this way. Therefore is there an argument that they should be exposed to this in the classroom?

#17 Parent Mancunian - 2013-02-03
Re: Re Beijing Huijia Private School

There are two sides for each coin - most FTs come there not to change a regime but to earn their living. You probably do so as well.

The other side of the coin is that there is racial discrimination by private, mostly crappy Chinese employers - I know of some concrete cases where black native speakers from the UK and the USA, though well qualified and experienced, and holders of either a UK or a US passport were rejected merely on grounds of their colour. Not a government matter at all but a private crappy employer matter. I have some Chinese friends, common folks working in a small restaurant, who told me "black people are ugly and dirty". It seems to be a widely held belief and attitude among Chinese people and attests to the daily, latent racism in this country. In this respect, China does not differ much from Western nations with the same problem in their respective societies.


I wouldn't doubt what you say; however, I have worked with black teachers in China who were well treated and well respected , working alongside their white colleagues; therefore, whilst believing your experiences, I have to say it isn't all bad. What I object to is the numerous posts I've seen written by non-white FT's(mainly Asian)-terribly written posts-bad English-bad attitude- complaining about this or that company; and the response that usually follows from seasoned posters is one of whole-hearted support and total belief that they have been given the absolute truth about the behaviour of the evil school. I don't believe that every complaining poster who gives it the 'blue-eyed gets better treatment bit' should be given unquestioned support....It could be that some of them are just trouble-making losers, as are some white blue-eyed FT's. Having said all that, I still believe, that most FT's should not be clouding their minds with all this negative stuff; it will make your stay in China a most unhappy one. Think positive and smile at the Chinese. wo shuo de you mei you dao li ne? Pimsleur is quite good, don't you think? Cheers&beers.
Return to Index › Re: Re Beijing Huijia Private School





Go to another board -