Learn to TEACH English with TECHNOLOGY. Free course for American TESOL students.


TESOL certification course online recognized by TESL Canada & ACTDEC UK.

Visit Driven Coffee Fundraising for unique school fundraising ideas.





Texas ISD School Guide
Texas ISD School Guide







Know Your Rights

Re: No hope for a Z Visa?
By:Mancunian
Date: 7 December 2012
In Response To: Re: No hope for a Z Visa? (Rebecca)

Non native speakers are used by those who are cutting corners and want to save money. Non native speakers are a disaster for students. Their intonation and pronunciation are completely wrong and destroy the learning of a student. Non native speakers are subservient and do not complain. They work for less money. Do you want to learn English and speak with a Philipino accent, strange grammar, and strange and wrong pronunciation?
English grammar is quite complex, and non native speakers have many aspects wrong and this too, is a disaster for students. There are many examples of this.
There is no substitute for a teacher who has RECENTLY lived in a Western English speaking country. It is the responsibility of the school or university to be certain that they are hiring a quality native speaker.

I was really shocked at the responses you have received, Rebecca- you seem to have attracted the type of mindless rhetoric straight out of Mao's great march forward. I cannot see anything racist in the deep concern for your students that it is clear you do have. i do think that the Chinese authorities have got a lot to answer for,for ever employing non native speakers to teach English in the first place. Colour does not matter at all, and I am sure you agree, as long as the foreign teacher is a native born speaker of English, and does not have an accent which will inhibit him or her from being understood by his students. I was discussing with a colleague the other day, that there must be more than twenty ways to say "the status of the rain has changed" a hundred to say 'it's cold.' Only a native born speaker is equipped with the knowledge required to teach English. Educational qualifications should be subservient to that knowledge.






Messages In This Thread

No hope for a Z Visa? -- JL -- 21 November 2012
Re: No hope for a Z Visa? -- juanisaac -- 23 November 2012
Re: No hope for a Z Visa? -- Magister -- 24 November 2012
Re: No hope for a Z Visa? -- Rebecca -- 30 November 2012
Re: No hope for a Z Visa? -- Turnoi -- 8 December 2012
Re: No hope for a Z Visa? -- Mancunian -- 10 December 2012
Re: No hope for a Z Visa? -- Sanjeevi -- 8 December 2012
Re: No hope for a Z Visa? -- Mancunian -- 7 December 2012
Re: No hope for a Z Visa? -- Steve UK -- 6 December 2012
Re: No hope for a Z Visa? -- foxy -- 7 December 2012
Re: No hope for a Z Visa? -- Mr.Smith -- 4 December 2012
Re: No hope for a Z Visa? -- John -- 4 December 2012
Re: No hope for a Z Visa? -- Magister -- 22 November 2012
Re: No hope for a Z Visa? -- Visa-Wise -- 21 November 2012

Go to another board -